Planning And Land Development Regulation Board Meeting Minutes For December 17, 2025 Business Meeting And January 21, 2026 Workshop Meeting
The board approved the December 17, 2025 business meeting minutes 7-0, then approved the January 21, 2026 workshop meeting minutes 7-0 in a separate vote.
Staff presented a rezoning request for a 10.44-acre parcel at 56 Hargrove Grade from IND1 to IND2 to allow Hard Rock Materials to construct a concrete batch plant.
The item had been continued from October 2025 due to concerns about water consumption and traffic; at this meeting, staff's contracted hydrogeologist reported no anticipated interference with city potable water wells at the corrected 25,000-gallon-per-day draw, and the city's traffic engineer presented an intersection evaluation showing the Hargrove Grade/US1 intersection currently operates at an acceptable level of service.
Board members questioned whether the existing-conditions-only traffic analysis was sufficient given future growth on the west side of Palm Coast, and the applicant's attorney explained the volunteer covenant restrictions cap trips at 200 per day — well below the theoretical maximum of 862 daily trips under full IND2 development.
The applicant also struck a covenant sentence the board had previously objected to, so that restrictions run with the land regardless of use.
Public comment was split, with neighboring IND1 business owners opposing the rezoning citing incompatibility, road deterioration, and precedent-setting concerns, while Hard Rock employees and a neighboring heavy industrial property owner supported it.
Staff recommended approval; the board approved 5-2.
Vote: Passed 5 to 2
Public comment on D.2 · 10 speakers
IND1 Business Compatibility and Chemical Safety Concerns
Opposition to rezoning from IND1 to IND2 at Hargrove Grade; cited city code section 2.05.05 regarding public interest, impact on existing IND1 businesses that invested based on current zoning, infrastructure not built for heavy industrial traffic, the single egress point at US1 and Hargrove Grade, and a NIOSH citation regarding hazardous gas from cement dust reacting with hydrochloric acid from the neighboring Sunbelt Chemicals facility.
Rezoning Incompatibility and Prior Application Precedent
Strong opposition to the rezoning; argued IND1 was designed for light industrial and warehousing and the batch plant is incompatible in scale and intensity; noted the two existing IND2 designations nearby predate the city and were not intentionally planned; raised concerns about dust, noise, truck traffic, roadway deterioration, health risks from cement particulates, and cited a prior rejected batch plant application at the same corridor as a precedent requiring consistency.
Road Infrastructure and Rezoning Precedent at Hargrove Grade
Opposition to rezoning representing 68 units and 50 owners at the Palm Coast Commercial Industrial Center on Hargrove Lane; stated the road cannot handle the volume of slow-moving cement trucks without a traffic signal at US1; noted roads at other sites with batch plants required specially engineered reinforced concrete pavement costing millions; argued the precedent of allowing one IND2 rezoning will lead to others, changing the character of the entire IND1 corridor.
Employee Support for Hargrove Grade Batch Plant
Support for the rezoning; stated the facility would reduce employee commute times, praised the board's deliberative process as a first-time attendee, and vouched for the company's character and professionalism as a current employee.
Industry Worker Supports Batch Plant Safety Record
Support for the rezoning; a 14-year concrete industry worker stated they have never experienced dust or acid-related hazards at facilities adjacent to neighborhoods, and noted the company operates a plant in Jacksonville adjacent to a residential area without complaints.
Resident Employee Supports Jobs and Batch Plant Approval
Support for the rezoning; a Hard Rock diesel technician and Palm Coast resident stated he drives Hargrove Grade daily and finds the intersection manageable, noted the 207/SR207 intersection is busier, and argued the plant would bring good-paying jobs and economic benefit to the community.
Driver Describes Clean Operations at Batch Plant
Support for the rezoning; a Hard Rock driver and recent Palm Coast resident described the truck loading and wash process as taking 20-25 minutes to ensure clean vehicles before road entry, emphasizing driver mindfulness toward the community.
Long-Time Concrete Industry Worker Supports Local Plant
Support for the rezoning; a Palm Coast resident since 2003 and former Rinker Materials employee now with Hard Rock praised the company's well-maintained trucks and trained drivers, and noted the economic value of a local concrete plant reducing travel time for deliveries throughout Palm Coast.
Wrong Fit for Hargrove Lane IND1 Corridor
Opposition to the rezoning from a business owner on Hargrove Lane; acknowledged the applicant appears to be a quality company but argued the site is not the right fit; raised concern that approving one IND2 rezoning will trigger others, changing the character of the corridor; noted several lot owners have put development plans on hold due to uncertainty about the rezoning outcome.
Heavy Industrial Neighbor Supports Batch Plant Rezoning
Support for the rezoning from the owner of the other IND2-zoned property on Hargrove Grade; stated he uses Hard Rock concrete in Jacksonville and St.
Augustine and finds their operations clean; noted his own dump trucks and heavy equipment use Hargrove Grade daily without issues; argued that Palm Coast's westward expansion will require more concrete, and that the Hargrove Grade railroad crossing will become a key east-west corridor for future industrial development.
Westward Expansion
D.3
Town Center Medical Technical Site Plan - Tier 2, Application # 6347
Staff presented a Tier 2 Technical Site Plan for two two-story medical office buildings totaling approximately 54,500 square feet on Track 10A within the Town Center master plan development, located northwest of AdventHealth along Town Center Boulevard.
The project conforms to the Town Center MPD development agreement, includes an accessory cafeteria, provides 198 parking spaces within the allowed 120% maximum, and meets all setback, height, floor-area ratio, and landscaping requirements.
No public comment was received.
The board approved unanimously 7-0.
Vote: Passed 7 to 0
E
Board Discussion And Staff Issues
F
Adjournment
Advisory Notes
— (context, D.2)
Multiple board members noted that the city's traffic intersection evaluation studied only existing conditions and did not account for future growth from west Palm Coast developments. The city's traffic engineer acknowledged the city lacks the internal tools to perform a full traffic impact analysis and that future growth was not factored in. This limitation in the traffic study methodology was a recurring point of contention throughout the board's deliberation.
— (context, D.2)
A speaker cited a prior concrete batch plant rezoning request at the same IND1 corridor that was rejected by both this board and city council, arguing that approving the current application creates policy inconsistency and potential legal exposure from the prior applicant. Staff did not address this prior-decision argument on the record.
— (context, D.2)
A speaker affiliated with a business at 15 Hargrove Lane cited a published NIOSH chemical safety guide regarding the reaction between hydrochloric acid and cement dust producing hazardous gases, raising a health and safety concern about proximity of the proposed batch plant to Sunbelt Chemicals. The applicant had addressed this topic in a demonstration video included in their application materials.
Opposition to rezoning from IND1 to IND2 at Hargrove Grade; cited city code section 2.05.05 regarding public interest, impact on existing IND1 businesses that invested based on current zoning, infrastructure not built for heavy industrial traffic, the single egress point at US1 and Hargrove Grade, and a NIOSH citation regarding hazardous gas from cement dust reacting with hydrochloric acid from the neighboring Sunbelt Chemicals facility.
Strong opposition to the rezoning; argued IND1 was designed for light industrial and warehousing and the batch plant is incompatible in scale and intensity; noted the two existing IND2 designations nearby predate the city and were not intentionally planned; raised concerns about dust, noise, truck traffic, roadway deterioration, health risks from cement particulates, and cited a prior rejected batch plant application at the same corridor as a precedent requiring consistency.
Opposition to rezoning representing 68 units and 50 owners at the Palm Coast Commercial Industrial Center on Hargrove Lane; stated the road cannot handle the volume of slow-moving cement trucks without a traffic signal at US1; noted roads at other sites with batch plants required specially engineered reinforced concrete pavement costing millions; argued the precedent of allowing one IND2 rezoning will lead to others, changing the character of the entire IND1 corridor.
Support for the rezoning; stated the facility would reduce employee commute times, praised the board's deliberative process as a first-time attendee, and vouched for the company's character and professionalism as a current employee.
Support for the rezoning; a 14-year concrete industry worker stated they have never experienced dust or acid-related hazards at facilities adjacent to neighborhoods, and noted the company operates a plant in Jacksonville adjacent to a residential area without complaints.
Support for the rezoning; a Hard Rock diesel technician and Palm Coast resident stated he drives Hargrove Grade daily and finds the intersection manageable, noted the 207/SR207 intersection is busier, and argued the plant would bring good-paying jobs and economic benefit to the community.
Support for the rezoning; a Hard Rock driver and recent Palm Coast resident described the truck loading and wash process as taking 20-25 minutes to ensure clean vehicles before road entry, emphasizing driver mindfulness toward the community.
Support for the rezoning; a Palm Coast resident since 2003 and former Rinker Materials employee now with Hard Rock praised the company's well-maintained trucks and trained drivers, and noted the economic value of a local concrete plant reducing travel time for deliveries throughout Palm Coast.
Opposition to the rezoning from a business owner on Hargrove Lane; acknowledged the applicant appears to be a quality company but argued the site is not the right fit; raised concern that approving one IND2 rezoning will trigger others, changing the character of the corridor; noted several lot owners have put development plans on hold due to uncertainty about the rezoning outcome.
Support for the rezoning from the owner of the other IND2-zoned property on Hargrove Grade; stated he uses Hard Rock concrete in Jacksonville and St.
Augustine and finds their operations clean; noted his own dump trucks and heavy equipment use Hargrove Grade daily without issues; argued that Palm Coast's westward expansion will require more concrete, and that the Hargrove Grade railroad crossing will become a key east-west corridor for future industrial development.