Palm Coast
storylines...

Independent Reporting · Palm Coast, Florida
Palm Coast City Council

Workshop Meeting — Tuesday, April 14, 2026

Processed 2026-07-02
Source Documents
Agenda PDF Approved Minutes PDF
Agenda
A
Call To Order
B
Pledge Of Allegiance To The Flag And A Moment Of Silence
C
Roll Call
D
Public Participation
Jeanie Duarte Candidate
Development concerns including Section 8 housing proliferation, 5G cell towers near schools and fire stations, airport expansion, a data center with only 15 jobs, overflowing manholes, herbicide spraying in swales and canals, reclaimed wastewater irrigation, a wastewater-to-potable-water pilot program, boil water notices, an appointed council seat, the city charter including the deputy manager position and prior charter amendments, and the charter review committee process.
Speaker
Request to add end-of-meeting public comment opportunity to council workshops; and inquiry about a Republican gubernatorial candidate's statement that municipalities exist only by virtue of state authorization, asking council members for their views on home rule.
Speaker
Motorcycle racing on Palm Coast Parkway between the Wawa and the Hammock bridge occurring on weekends and weekday evenings, lack of sheriff enforcement presence, safety concerns given prior fatalities, and a request for the city to contact Sheriff Staly about increased patrols.
Speaker
Corroboration of the motorcycle racing problem on Palm Coast Parkway near the Hammock bridge, noting audible high-speed activity from nearby residence and the existence of a memorial plaque for a prior fatality in the area.
E
Presentations
E.1
Presentation - Annual Investment Report
PFM Asset Management representatives Danessa Matts and Leslie Weber presented the annual investment report as of December 31, 2025. The long-term portfolio of approximately $90 million is roughly half in U.S. Treasuries and 25% in corporate notes, with an overall credit quality of AA and yield at cost of 4.23%, outperforming the benchmark by approximately 40 basis points. Interest earnings for the year totaled approximately $3.76 million with total accrual-basis earnings near $4 million. Finance Director Helena Alves confirmed the city is in the pre-closing phase for its municipal bond issuance, with final closing expected the following week and funding by April 23. Bond proceeds will be invested in a separate portfolio managed in coordination with utility cash flow needs.
E.2
Presentation - Palm Harbor Golf Club Quarter 2 Update
Parks and Recreation Director James Hurst and Recreation Manager Dennis Reagan presented the Q2 update for Palm Harbor Golf Club. Key changes implemented since October 2025 include a fee increase (average round up from $28.22 to $37.61), elimination of free golf on pass holder cards, a walkers punch pass program (152 sold at $200 each), limiting morning 9-hole play, hosting tournaments generating nearly $100,000 in economic impact, and initiating hole sponsorships. Year-to-date revenue as of the presentation date reached $1.28 million, with a projected full-year surplus of approximately $72,625. Upcoming capital needs include a pump station replacement ($278K budgeted) and 50 golf cart replacements (~$294K net). Council praised the turnaround and raised questions about cart leasing vs. purchasing, whether all costs are fully captured, and the potential for an enterprise fund structure.
E.3
Presentation - Rfi For Palm Harbor Golf Club
Director Hurst presented results of the RFI for Palm Harbor Golf Club management, which drew eight submissions from operators including American Golf Corporation, Bobby Jones Links, Troon Golf, and others. Proposals ranged from full management to hybrid and lease arrangements; all expressed support for resident affordability and public transparency. Council debated whether to proceed with an RFP for management/lease or continue city operations. Vice Mayor Pontieri and Council Members Sullivan and Miller expressed opposition to an RFP at this time, citing staff performance, negative signals to employees, food-and-beverage constraints from the Loopers lease, and lack of capital investment commitments in RFI responses. Mayor Norris and Council Member Gambaro were open to exploring an RFP with strict parameters. One public commenter (Greg Evans, affiliated with Palm Harbor Golf Course LLC) presented a detailed investment proposal. After public comment, the apparent consensus shifted against proceeding with an RFP; the city manager was directed to ensure golf course revenues are reinvested in the course and to research whether an enterprise fund designation is feasible.
E.4
Presentation - Proposed Charter Amendments
City Attorney Marcus Duffy presented three proposed charter amendments drafted per prior council direction, with Supervisor of Elections Katie Lenhart and bond counsel Chris Roe present. Amendment 1 would add a process requiring three censures and a supermajority vote before council may send a letter to the governor requesting removal of a member, with specified grounds including felony conviction, absence, and ethics violations. Council requested clarifications including: separating felony grounds from the three-censure requirement, specifying the censures apply per term, defining 'meetings' to include workshops, and clarifying who determines ethics violations. Amendment 2 would establish procedures for filling council vacancies based on timing relative to the next general election, with election blackout periods. Council found the draft overly complex and directed the attorney to use a 'scalpel approach,' working with the Supervisor of Elections to fix only the core gap exposed by the 2024 vacancy situation without creating additional complications. Amendment 3 would raise the unfunded multi-year contract limit from $15 million/36 months to $30 million/30 years with annual CPI indexing. Council accepted this amendment with only minor corrections noted. All amendments are targeted for the November 2026 ballot with an August deadline.
E.5
Presentation - Sr 100 Corridor Community Redevelopment Area (cra)
Community Development Director John Zobel and Economic Development Manager Craig McKinney presented an overview of the SR 100 Corridor CRA, which sunsets in 2034. The CRA has significantly underperformed projections: cumulative property values are $286 million vs. a projected $1.1 billion, and annual revenue is $2.9 million vs. a projected $7.6 million. Total revenues collected since inception are approximately $33 million vs. a projected $161 million. Remaining projected revenues through 2034 total approximately $27 million. Staff recommended hiring a consultant (Kimley-Horn at a revised scope of ~$96,770) to perform a comprehensive review, TIF analysis, and updated strategic plan. The Town Center Boulevard road condition and YMCA funding from CRA were also discussed. Council reached consensus to proceed with the consultant contract and directed staff to ensure the YMCA CRA allocation is reviewed before further commitment.
E.6
Presentation - Development Options For Duplex Zoned Lots
Planning Manager Long Fong and planner Estelle Lenz presented development options for approximately 1,181 originally platted ITT duplex-zoned lots. Current code allows a duplex structure or a split lot with a duplex structure. Option 3 would allow splitting any duplex lot and building a single-family home on each half (40-ft min width, 4,000 sq ft min lot, 1,000 sq ft min living area, one-car garage, 5-ft interior setback). Option 4 would restrict that to affordable housing with AMI and affordability period requirements. Council did not reach consensus to immediately adopt an ordinance. Concerns were raised about impact fees, PEP tank duplication, neighborhood compatibility, property values, and enforcement of affordability restrictions. Council directed staff to provide ownership data for the duplex lots (identifying clusters) and to bring the matter back alongside the housing study in May, at which point council will give direction on whether to proceed via ordinance or LDC update.
E.7
Presentation - 10-year Capital Improvement Plan (cip)
Utility Director Brian (last name not stated clearly) and Finance/Public Works Director Carl presented the 10-year Capital Improvement Plan. The utility CIP totals approximately $590 million over five years, funded through bond proceeds ($283M), capital facilities charges ($130M), R&R reserves (~$117M), grants ($11M+), and SRF loans. Major projects include expansion of Wastewater Plant 1 from 6.83 to 10.83 MGD (~$180-200M), rehabilitation of Water Treatment Plant 1 (~$50M), new wells, Water Plant 3 expansion, and I&I/PEP system work. The non-utility CIP covered the Capital Projects Fund (small county surtax, ~$5M/year), park and fire impact fee funds, transportation impact fee funds including the $126M Loop Road appropriation, stormwater, and the CRA. The pavement management program was noted as underfunded. Council expressed particular concern about water quality from Plant 1, emphasizing it as a top resident priority. Transportation fairness with FDOT/TPO was also noted as an ongoing advocacy issue.
Loop Road
E.8
Presentation - Software Strategy And Risk Mitigation Council Sap
IT Director Doug Atkins presented a software strategy and risk mitigation plan developed through an Application Portfolio Management framework. An inventory of approximately 100 city applications was scored on business value and technical fit using Gartner's TIME model. The analysis identified fragmentation in work orders, asset management, inventory management, and performance reporting as the top operational gap. This finding aligned with Plante Moran's risk assessment, which ranked inadequate asset tracking as the city's second-highest risk. Staff recommended pursuing an Enterprise Asset Management (EAM) platform as the top software priority, estimated at approximately $450,000 for first-year implementation and $150,000 annually thereafter. Council reached consensus to proceed with developing an RFP for the EAM platform, to be incorporated in the upcoming budget process, with a request for ROI analysis to accompany the RFP when it returns.
F
Public Participation
Speaker
Described a drainage event on April 8, 2026, during which the swale in front of his property filled to near road level while an adjacent property built approximately 3 feet 2 inches higher continued shedding water onto his lower property after the swale was already at capacity. He filed a Palm Coast Connect request that was closed the next morning with a generic response about standing water being normal. He questioned why the city's technical manual limits on elevation differences between properties are not being enforced on new construction, citing 140 Frontier as a property appearing to exceed those limits.
capacity
Speaker
Noted that the real estate market has slowed considerably and urged council to factor that into deliberations; commended the council for unanimously and independently agreeing the golf course should not be sold; proposed that council direct the city attorney to place a perpetual covenant on the 147-acre golf course property restricting it to recreational use, to provide a permanent legal foundation for staff and future councils.
Dee Galery Candidate
Positive comments about the Citizens Academy program; suggested it be offered more than twice per year (currently spring and fall) to allow more residents to participate.
G
Discussion By City Council Of Matters Not On The Agenda
H
Discussion By City Attorney Of Matters Not On The Agenda
I
Discussion By City Manager Of Matters Not On The Agenda
J
Adjournment
J.1
Agenda Worksheet And Calendar
J.1
Presentation
Public Comment
Tony Amaral Jr. Candidate
Question about the city's strategy for investing the incoming municipal bond proceeds in the short term given that the funds will be drawn down over 8-10 years for utility projects.
Speaker
Urged council not to issue an RFP for golf course management, noting the city gave Dennis Reagan six months to show improvement and he has delivered; stated RFPs have been tried previously and failed; asked council to give him at least a full year before considering outside management.
Speaker
Argued council is being short-sighted by considering an RFP given the $430,000 revenue swing achieved in six months under current management; stated the RFP sends a negative message to staff and the golf course is on an ascent; expressed strong opposition to any outside management.
Speaker
Military background perspective supporting continued city management; emphasized the course is owned by the community and cautioned about risks of handing management to outside entities; urged 'crawl, walk, run' approach and called for more time.
Speaker
Member of Palm Harbor Ladies Golf League for five years; spoke to the social and exercise value of the course for women golfers; noted 55,000 tee times last year for 100,000 residents as evidence of demand; opposed any change that could reduce access or increase fees; asked council to keep the course as a public amenity comparable to other recreational facilities that don't generate profit.
Speaker
Praised Vice Mayor Pontieri's analysis; urged council not to issue RFP; warned that outside operators will extract profit and not reinvest; suggested a public-private partnership limited to specific improvements like a new clubhouse rather than full management transfer; referenced poor prior contract history at the city.
Speaker
Noted prior eight-year Kemper Sports management contract during which the city lost money while the contractor profited; urged council to keep Dennis Reagan in place; suggested establishing an enterprise fund to ensure golf course revenues are reinvested in the course.
Speaker
Long-term Palm Coast resident (since 2003) who lives on the golf course; spoke to the historical importance of the course to Palm Coast's founding and identity; raised concerns about ulterior motives behind RFP advocacy; praised the course staff including the greenkeeper Roger; urged council to stop RFP discussions and let Dennis Reagan continue.
Speaker
Lives on the golf course for 10 years; opposes outside management; stated the course is on the verge of being self-sufficient; praised current staff including the greenskeeping crew; asked council to give management more time.
Speaker
Golfer who plays three to four rounds per week at Palm Harbor; praised Dennis Reagan's management and the competitive fee structure; warned that outside operators could raise green fees significantly and that affordability for residents should be the priority.
Speaker
Question about whether Palm Harbor Golf Course has applied for listing on the Florida Historic Golf Trail, noting it meets the age criterion and that listing could provide free advertising and potential grant opportunities.
Speaker
Expressed opposition to the RFP in colorful terms; stated Dennis Reagan deserves a bonus for his performance; compared the turnaround favorably to significant public sector achievements.
Speaker
Identified as a resident and member of the group that submitted the RFI as Palm Harbor Golf Course LLC; presented a detailed private investment proposal including Ron Garl course evaluation, outdoor food and beverage expansion, 30-bay technology driving range, new clubhouse, enhanced parking, and partnership with Loopers — all privately funded with zero city dollars; offered to take council to Clermont National Golf Course to view similar work; noted four of seven team members live in or near Palm Coast.
Speaker
Long-time resident recalling ITT-era golf courses; member of a private club and Palm Harbor league; argued Palm Harbor is and should remain a short municipal course for seniors and local residents on fixed incomes; opposed any transformation to a higher-end facility; urged council to keep it as a 'muni' and stay with current management.
Speaker
Questions about Charter Amendment 1 regarding censures: whether three censures must be separate events or could relate to the same event, whether they are per term or lifetime, and what happens if a councilmember is censured twice, re-elected, then censured once more. Also raised concern about ambiguity in Amendment 1 item 4 regarding who determines an ethics violation.
Speaker
Expressed concern that the CRA has been a vehicle for incentivizing apartment complexes rather than the high-quality retail, recreation, and community amenities envisioned for Town Center; questioned whether ITT-donated land obligations have been honored; called for investigation of the CRA and suggested it should be eliminated; opposed expanding the CRA boundary into environmentally sensitive lands or adding industrial uses.
Speaker
Acknowledged the CRA underperformance was largely due to the 2008 housing crash; expressed support for extending the CRA and noted the seven-year gap in activity; emphasized the need to start the extension process early given it requires county and state agreement; noted properties purchased with CRA funds (including land where City Hall sits) as examples of the tool working.
Speaker
Argued the CRA has been a free ride for properties within its boundaries at the expense of taxpayers outside it; opposed extending the CRA's sunset; noted roads in Town Center are in poor condition; questioned the original justification for the CRA (Whispering Pines); urged council to let the CRA expire rather than extend it.
Darlene Shelley Candidate
As a residential home builder, presented a detailed analysis of how stacking policy incentives (lot split, reduced garage requirement, reduced minimum square footage, deferred impact fees via SHIP/CDBG liens) could reduce a home's cost by over $100,000, making it attainable for workforce households. Clarified that duplex lots already have separate PEP tanks per unit, that affordability monitoring is limited to qualification at time of purchase rather than ongoing income verification, and that a pilot program is achievable now without a full ordinance change. Stated the proposal is not about subsidized housing but about removing barriers for working households.
Speaker
Opposed the duplex lot split proposal; stated it is incompatible with the character of existing single-family neighborhoods; raised concerns about property value impacts from small homes on narrow lots; suggested the proposal benefits developers rather than homeowners; requested ownership data on the 1,181 duplex lots before any action is taken; noted existing affordable options in the city.
Tony Amaral Jr. Candidate
Called for an actual, executable plan to address workforce housing affordability rather than ongoing studies and committee work; noted affordability affects the city's ability to recruit and retain essential workers including firefighters and teachers; expressed support for moving forward with a concrete initiative.
Speaker
Question about what the 6-cent local option fuel tax funds and why it does not appear to address pothole repair, road deterioration, or shoulder work; suggested the city consider working with the county to suspend or reduce the tax given that transportation needs are not being met.
Tony Amaral Jr. Candidate
Commended the 10-year CIP presentation for providing transparency on where city funds are directed; asked about a spike in transportation impact fee revenue in FY2028 compared to surrounding years; also asked about the status of peak-hour trip counts on Royal Palms relative to the threshold triggering a box culvert requirement under the Town Center DRI amendment.
Advisory Notes
— (public_comment, E.3) A speaker identified as Greg Evans stated he represents a seven-person group including a former Universal Studios vice president of attractions, a Fortune 200 company COO, and the owner of Loopers restaurant, who submitted an RFI response under 'Palm Harbor Golf Course LLC.' The speaker offered a detailed investment proposal including engagement of golf course designer Ron Garl, construction of a 30-bay technology-enabled driving range, outdoor food and beverage expansion, new clubhouse, and enhanced parking — all funded with private capital, no city funds. The speaker offered to bus council, staff, and press to Clermont National Golf Course (which his group operates) as a demonstration. This constitutes a substantive private-sector pitch for a public-private partnership on a city asset currently under review.
— (context, G) Vice Mayor Pontieri delivered extended remarks in the council discussion period asserting that the westward expansion landowner's proposed Master Planned Development (MPD) — described as 117 pages — fails to honor obligations in existing development orders, which she states required the landowner to pay for the Loop Road (now funded by $126M in state appropriations), a sports complex including an Olympic-size pool, and sports fields, and imposed sequencing requirements mandating commercial development before residential. She stated the new MPD adds approximately 10,000 dwelling units beyond prior approvals without those contributions, and that she will not accept it in its current form. She directed a public appeal to the landowner to revise the proposal.
— (context, E.5) During the CRA presentation, it was disclosed that a $900,000 transfer from the CRA to the park impact fee fund (for YMCA) was included in the current approved budget, a fact Vice Mayor Pontieri said she was unaware of and had not been discussed as a council direction. The city manager clarified it went through the budget adoption process. This exchange signals a potential oversight or communication gap between staff budget preparation and council awareness of specific fund transfers.
← All Meetings