The board approved minutes from the August 19, 2026 business meeting and the September 16, 2026 workshop meeting in separate unanimous votes.
Because most members were new and had not attended those meetings, the three returning members verbally confirmed the accuracy of the minutes before each vote.
City Attorney Marcus Duffy presented a draft Historical Preservation Ordinance developed at city council's direction, which would create a formal Historic Preservation Board, designate a Historic Preservation Officer, establish criteria for local historic designation, require cultural resource surveys before development permits on unsurveyed or flagged properties, and align the city with the state's Certified Local Government program.
The ordinance expands on the city's existing two-and-a-half-page cultural resource provision into a comprehensive 32-page framework.
Board discussion focused on qualification requirements for the officer position, flagging properties in the city's permitting system, benefits and costs of designation, and the role of the Palm Coast Historical Society.
The board unanimously recommended approval with conditions: adding a permanent voting seat on the board for the Palm Coast Historical Society, and requiring that the Historic Preservation Officer hold an advanced degree in architectural history, urban design, local history, landscape, site planning, or land use regulations.
The board considered an amendment to the Magnolia Trace Master Planned Development Agreement (formerly OARE MPD), a roughly 1,000-acre site south of SR-100 along Beltree Road.
The applicant, Greenpoint Holdings LLC under contract with ORE Associates, presented a proposal to reduce the maximum residential unit count from 754 to 544, eliminate a planned access road through the Z-section neighborhood in favor of internal connectivity, expand the neighborhood commercial tract, and add acreage into the MPD while preserving over 715 acres in conservation easements.
Staff found the amendment consistent with the comprehensive plan and land development code, and recommended approval with the condition that minimum interior town home lot width be increased from 18 to 20 feet.
The board added a condition requiring a historical marker at the site of the Gore Lake Mound, and modified the town home width condition to direct staff and the applicant to work together on a possible hybrid solution before city council action.
The item was recommended for approval 6-1 and is scheduled for first reading at city council on October 6, 2026.
Drainage concerns related to the Magnolia Trace development: a resident on Kashmir Trail whose property abuts the conservation area raised concerns about where stormwater from the development would drain, citing flooding during the 2005 hurricane season that brought water to the rear of her property, and questioning the impact of removing what she characterized as 300 acres from conservation on the area's flood storage capacity.
Archaeological site verification: a speaker urged the board to confirm that the state had formally accepted and approved the phase 3 archaeological report for the Gore Lake Mound site, distinguishing between submission of the report and actual state approval, and noting that if properly completed it represents a good example of responsible handling of such situations.
Hydrological and wetland connectivity impacts: a speaker with a background in landscape ecology raised concerns about isolated wetlands becoming flooded due to impervious surface increases, potential tree die-off from altered hydroperiods documented by St.
Johns River Water Management District on similar projects, the need for culverts rather than fill on the internal road crossing to maintain wetland flow, and a request for an explicit perpetual conservation commitment for Tracks 3 and 4 under Florida Statutes 304.6.
Concerns about changing maps between presentations, the borrow pit in Tracks 3 and 4, the shift from assisted retirement to multifamily with third-party rental, elimination of an emergency access point, the width of proposed lots relative to existing neighborhood lots, and traffic safety at the proposed Beltree Road access point.
Legal consistency challenge: a speaker representing a large group of residents argued the application should be denied because the comprehensive plan requires wetland avoidance first, filling forested wetlands in Black Branch Swamp does not meet that standard, the flood plain regulations require development not increase offsite flood risk, and the density increases in prior approvals were premised on the public benefit of a continuing care facility that is now off the table — making the current amendment a fundamental change of purpose.
Heard before · Item D.2 · Sep 22, 2026
Aug 11, 2026 · City Council · Item E.3 · workshop
Sep 22, 2026 · Planning board · Item D.2 · this meeting
Oct 6, 2026 · City Council · Item H.5 · first reading — 5-0 (from the captions; not yet checked against the video)
Oct 20, 2026 · City Council · Item I.8 · second reading — Passed (from the captions; not yet checked against the video)
City Attorney Duffy presented a draft historical preservation ordinance (Chapter 10.05) that would create a city register of historic places, require cultural resource surveys for lands not previously investigated, establish a Historical Preservation Officer position (appointed by city manager), and create a five-member preservation board (reduced from seven per council direction) with two alternates meeting at least four times per year.
Key council feedback included adding a temporal limit on prior survey exemptions (e.g., 10-year expiration), ensuring historic designations are recorded in title records to notify future buyers, and reducing board membership to five primary plus two alternates.
The ordinance will proceed to the planning board and then return for two council readings.
Exception from the cultural resource survey for existing platted lots (handed over from the land code update). Oct 6 packet p.2004
Raised Oct 6 · by not stated · source: agenda packet
Made Oct 6: The draft ordinance says no survey is required for any parcel or lot in a recorded platted subdivision in the city. Oct 6 packet p.1597
“shall not be required for any parcel or lot that is part of a platted subdivision”
Add a temporal component (expiration period, e.g., 10 years) to sections 10.05.03 and 10.05.04 so that prior cultural resource surveys do not exempt a parcel indefinitely.
Raised Aug 11 · by council · source: meeting video (captions) · 04:10:11
Made Oct 6: Section 10.05.03 now includes a 5-year temporal limit on prior cultural resource surveys, so a prior survey only waives the requirement if conducted within the last 5 years. Oct 6 packet p.1583
Not yet checked against the video.Staff will research what time period the state requires for survey renewal and consider adding a renewal threshold to the ordinance.
Raised Aug 11 · by staff · source: meeting video (captions) · 04:10:57
Made Oct 6: The ordinance adopted a 5-year renewal threshold for prior surveys, reflecting the research staff promised to conduct on the appropriate time period. Oct 6 packet p.1583
Not yet checked against the video.Reduce the preservation board membership from seven members with two alternates to five members with two alternates.
Raised Aug 11 · by council · source: meeting video (captions) · 04:19:59
Not addressed in the pages reviewed Oct 6: The packet pages provided do not contain any text specifying the number of preservation board members or alternates.
Not yet checked against the video.Staff will ensure that a historic designation is recorded so that it appears in a title report and puts future buyers on notice.
Raised Aug 11 · by staff · source: meeting video (captions) · 04:34:02
Made Oct 6: The ordinance requires the city clerk to record the designation resolution in the official records of the county, putting future buyers on notice through the public record. Oct 6 packet p.1640
“The city clerk, who shall record such resolution in the official records of the county;”Not yet checked against the video.
Clarify whether small individual lots (e.g., an 80-by-125-foot lot) are required to undergo a cultural resource investigation and what that would cost.
Raised Aug 11 · by public comment · source: meeting video (captions) · 04:27:02
Partly made Oct 6: The packet clarifies that platted subdivision lots within city boundaries are exempt from cultural resource surveys, and that a Registered Professional Archaeologist may certify a low-probability determination as a waiver, but no cost information for small lots is provided. Oct 6 packet p.1583
“Any previous parcel or lot that is part of a platted subdivision within the City boundaries and recorded with the Clerk of Circuit Court and Comptroller of Flagler County.”Not yet checked against the video.
Clarify whether city-owned structures such as fire station 22, which are being substantially altered, would be subject to this ordinance.
Raised Aug 11 · by public comment · source: meeting video (captions) · 04:27:56
Not addressed in the pages reviewed Oct 6: The packet pages provided contain no discussion of city-owned structures such as fire stations or whether they are subject to this ordinance.
Not yet checked against the video.Staff should add a temporal component (a time threshold, such as every 10 years) to sections 10.05.03 and 10.05.04 so that a prior cultural resources survey does not exempt a property indefinitely.
Raised Aug 11 · by council · source: meeting video (captions) · 04:10:11
Partly made Oct 20: The packet adds a 5-year time threshold for prior survey exemptions in section 10.05.03, addressing the temporal component requested, though council had suggested 10 years as an example. Oct 20 packet p.3663
“A cultural resource report is waived for parcels surveyed within the last 5 years.”Not yet checked against the video.
The city attorney will research what time period the state requires for survey renewal and will add a renewal time limit to the exemption provisions.
Raised Aug 11 · by staff · source: meeting video (captions) · 04:10:59
Partly made Oct 20: The ordinance now includes a 5-year renewal limit on the survey exemption, though the packet does not explicitly state this was based on state-required research by the city attorney. Oct 20 packet p.3663
“A cultural resource report is waived for parcels surveyed within the last 5 years.”Not yet checked against the video.
Reduce the historical preservation board membership from seven members with two alternates to five members with two alternates.
Raised Aug 11 · by council · source: meeting video (captions) · 04:19:59
Made Oct 20: The board composition was reduced to five members with two alternates as directed by council. Oct 20 packet p.3666
“Five Members and Two Alternates”Not yet checked against the video.
The ordinance should include a requirement that a historic designation be recorded so it appears in a title report and puts future buyers on notice.
Raised Aug 11 · by council · source: meeting video (captions) · 04:33:53
Made Oct 20: The ordinance requires the city clerk to record the historic designation resolution in the official records of the county, putting future buyers on notice. Oct 20 packet p.3688
“The city clerk, who shall record such resolution in the official records of the county”Not yet checked against the video.
The city attorney will ensure the ordinance explicitly requires that historic designations are recorded in public records.
Raised Aug 11 · by staff · source: meeting video (captions) · 04:34:04
Made Oct 20: The ordinance explicitly requires the city clerk to record the designation resolution in official county records. Oct 20 packet p.3688
“The city clerk, who shall record such resolution in the official records of the county”Not yet checked against the video.
Council and staff should clarify whether every individual residential lot, including small platted lots, must undergo a cultural resources survey before a permit is issued, and what that would cost.
Raised Aug 11 · by public comment · source: meeting video (captions) · 04:27:02
Partly made Oct 20: The packet addresses platted subdivision lots by exempting any platted subdivision lot recorded with the Clerk of Circuit Court, but does not address cost concerns raised by the public. Oct 20 packet p.3663
“Any previous parcel or lot that is part of a platted subdivision within the City boundaries and recorded with the Clerk of Circuit Court and Comptroller of Flagler County.”Not yet checked against the video.
Staff should address whether city-owned structures such as fire station 22 would be subject to the ordinance's historic review requirements when altered.
Raised Aug 11 · by public comment · source: meeting video (captions) · 04:27:56
Not addressed in the pages reviewed Oct 20: The packet pages provided do not mention city-owned structures such as fire station 22 or whether they are subject to historic review requirements.
Not yet checked against the video.The ordinance is to be approved with the planning board's recommendations incorporated, not as originally drafted.
Raised Oct 6 · by council · source: meeting video (captions) · 05:25:11
Made Oct 20: The background states that the requested updates and the Planning & Land Development Regulation Board recommendation are attached and incorporated into the ordinance. Oct 20 packet p.3658
Not yet checked against the video.One voting member of the historic preservation board must come from the Palm Coast Historical Society, as recommended by the planning board.
Raised Oct 6 · by staff · source: meeting video (captions) · 05:22:11
Made Oct 20: The ordinance includes one voting member from the Palm Coast Historical Society as recommended by the planning board. Oct 20 packet p.3666
“One voting member from Palm Coast Historical Society (PLDRB Board Recommendation)”Not yet checked against the video.
Council asked staff to clarify and confirm whether a member of the Palm Coast Historical Society can legally serve as a voting member rather than an advisory or ex-officio member.
Raised Oct 6 · by council · source: meeting video (captions) · 05:23:32
Made Oct 20: The packet confirms the Palm Coast Historical Society representative is designated as a voting member, resolving the legal question raised by council. Oct 20 packet p.3666
“One voting member from Palm Coast Historical Society (PLDRB Board Recommendation)”Not yet checked against the video.
Promised The city council may amend or rescind any historic designation subject to the same procedures used in the original designation. Oct 20 packet p.3688
Sources: the Sep 22, 2026 agenda packet (page numbers link to the page), and PalmCoastStorylines meeting records for August 11, 2026, built from the city's agenda packets and meeting video. Summaries and votes from those meetings are generated from the captions and are unverified unless marked otherwise; the video is the record. Full packet →
Background · Item D.3 · Sep 22, 2026
Sep 22, 2026 · Planning board · Item D.3 · this meeting Oct 6 packet p.193
Oct 6, 2026 · City Council · Item H.1 · first reading — 4-1 (Miller yes; Pontieri yes; Sullivan yes; Gambaro yes; Norris no) (from the captions; not yet checked against the video)
Oct 20, 2026 · City Council · Item I.1 · second reading — Passed 4 to 1 (from the captions; not yet checked against the video)
Applicant agreed to add language to the MPD requiring the owner to provide an interpretive display about the Gore Lake Mound in a project amenity center.
Raised Oct 6 · by applicant · source: meeting video (captions) · 01:58:34
Made Oct 20: Section 10.21 of the MPD now requires the Owner to include an interpretive display about the Gore Lake Mound in an amenity center developed within the Project. Oct 20 packet p.1563
“10.21 GORE LAKE MOUND HISTORICAL MARKER: The Owner shall include information and an interpretive display about the Gore Lake Mound in an amenity center developed within the Project.”Not yet checked against the video.
The conversion table in Exhibit E and the related section 7.2 language shall be deleted, with Exhibit F renumbered to Exhibit E and section 7.2 marked 'intentionally deleted.'
Raised Oct 6 · by council · source: meeting video (captions) · 02:12:12
Not made Oct 20: The packet shows Section 7.2 and the conversion table (Exhibit E) were retained in the MPD; page 1 lists the conversion chart deletion as a council comment but page 66 shows Section 7.2 with the full conversion table language still present. Oct 20 packet p.1550
Not yet checked against the video.The minimum town home lot width shall be changed from 18 feet to 20 feet in the development standards table at section 12.1.
Raised Oct 6 · by council · source: meeting video (captions) · 02:22:35
Made Oct 20: The packet confirms that Table 12.1 was amended to increase the minimum townhome lot width from 18 feet to 20 feet. Oct 20 packet p.1486
“Table 12.1 Site Development Requirements. The minimum townhome lot width is increased from 18' to 20'.”Not yet checked against the video.
The perimeter buffer language shall be changed from permissive ('may') to mandatory ('shall') requiring preservation of existing natural vegetative state unless alteration is necessary for stormwater management.
Raised Oct 6 · by council · source: meeting video (captions) · 01:42:39
Partly made Oct 20: The buffer language was amended to require reasonable efforts to retain natural buffers and mandatory supplemental planting where screening is inadequate, but exceptions allowing replacement remain permissive under specified stormwater and development conditions, not a simple 'shall preserve unless stormwater necessary' formulation. Oct 20 packet p.1562
Not yet checked against the video.The MPD shall clarify that multifamily units are restricted to tract one (neighborhood commercial track) and that active adult housing in tract two shall not include multifamily.
Raised Oct 6 · by council · source: meeting video (captions) · 02:42:20
Partly made Oct 20: The MPD limits multifamily to Tract 1 and caps aggregate multifamily/townhome units at 150, but the packet does not explicitly state that Active Adult Housing in Tract 2 excludes multifamily; Tract 2 permitted uses include 'Active Adult Housing' separately from multifamily, though the restriction is implied rather than expressly stated. Oct 20 packet p.1567
“Multifamily units developed on Tract 1, whether stand-alone or as part of mixed-use buildings, shall count toward the 150-unit aggregate cap on multifamily housing units and townhomes set forth in Section 7.1.”Not yet checked against the video.
Applicant agreed to correct a typographical error in section 4 of the MPD, changing the comprehensive plan policy reference from 1.1.2.4 to 1.1.2.3 (the green belt consolidation policy).
Raised Oct 6 · by applicant · source: meeting video (captions) · 02:02:19
Not addressed in the pages reviewed Oct 20: These pages contain no mention of a typographical error correction in Section 4 changing comprehensive plan policy reference from 1.1.2.4 to 1.1.2.3.
Not yet checked against the video.Applicant agreed to correct the borrow pit access road description from 'existing' to 'permitted' to accurately reflect the permit status.
Raised Oct 6 · by applicant · source: meeting video (captions) · 02:01:38
Not addressed in the pages reviewed Oct 20: These pages contain no mention of correcting the borrow pit access road description from 'existing' to 'permitted.'
Not yet checked against the video.Council directed staff to check whether the two drainage canals running from the Z-section into the swamp have been cleaned recently or are scheduled for cleaning, and to report back.
Raised Oct 6 · by council · source: meeting video (captions) · 03:07:34
Deferred Oct 20: The packet does not report back on canal cleaning status but instead indicates that stormwater staff will provide a presentation on the development review process to address stormwater concerns. Oct 20 packet p.1486
“stormwater staff will provide a presentation on the development review process to demonstrate that stormwater system meets conditions to prevent flooding of other properties”Not yet checked against the video.
Public commenter requested that the drainage flow map be placed into the record and that an updated drainage analysis using recent rainfall data, current flooding conditions, and cumulative development impacts be required before approval.
Raised Oct 6 · by public comment · source: meeting video (captions) · 02:53:37
Not made Oct 20: The packet does not require an updated drainage analysis using recent rainfall and cumulative impact data before approval; instead it notes stormwater is the owner's responsibility and that a staff presentation will address the review process, without ordering a new analysis. Oct 20 packet p.1485
“Section 9 (e). Language has been clarified that stormwater and stormwater runoff is responsibility of owner and must be conveyed to master stormwater system for project.”Not yet checked against the video.
Promised Stormwater staff will provide a presentation on the development review process to demonstrate that the stormwater system meets conditions to prevent flooding of other properties. Oct 20 packet p.1486
Sources: the Sep 22, 2026 agenda packet (page numbers link to the page). Full packet →
Support for the Historical Preservation Ordinance: the city's historian noted the existing ordinance is only two and a half pages with no enforcement history, confirmed the proposed ordinance is not highly restrictive but rather clarifies and expands the existing framework, and thanked the city attorney for his work developing it.
Comment thanking the board for requesting a historical marker at the Gore Lake Mound site in connection with the Magnolia Trace project.
Support for the Historical Preservation Ordinance from the president of the Palm Coast Historical Society, citing the Magnolia Trace archaeological process as a model for what should be standard practice, noting that fire station 22 and the Palm Harbor Golf Course were among the impetuses for the program, and expressing support for the tax incentives and preservation benefits the CLG program would provide.
Concern that the word 'cultural' was removed from the ordinance criteria, and that ITT platted lots should not be broadly exempted from cultural resource survey requirements given that many contain undisturbed wetlands where archaeological materials — including submerged artifacts — may be found.