Palm Coast
storylines...

Independent Reporting · Palm Coast, Florida
Published

Shooting Down the Butterfly: The Expert Witness


Bunnell’s commission denied the landfill. For the full account, see FlaglerLive and the Observer.

Michael Hill, a planner, takes the proposed Bunnell landfill apart, piece by piece.

Hill is an up-and-coming land use planner from Gainesville.

Michael Hill testifies 9:28

Michael Hill, principal of Torreya Design & Consulting, at the Bunnell City Commission’s special meeting, Oct. 28, 2026.

Watch the full meeting: Bunnell City Commission special meeting, Part 2.

— Johnny Diamond  ·  PalmCoastStorylines.com

De Novo: Start the Case Over


Latin for “from the start.”

The landfill was approved by Bunnell’s Planning Board. That decision was appealed to the City Commission. At the commission’s hearing, the applicant’s side said it had agreed the hearing would be de novo, which it described as the commission making the decision anew, on the evidence presented that day.

So the commission wasn’t there to grade the board’s work. It was there to hear the whole case fresh.

That is why a point of order came up as Mr. Hill testified. Asked whether the board’s decision rested on competent substantial evidence, he said it did not. A voice on the dais objected: in a de novo hearing the commission isn’t to consider what the board said or evaluated. This is a new review of the facts.

The lawyer who called him answered that his opinion was about the application itself, which is what the commission was reviewing.

That is the dividing line. A complaint about what the board got wrong was beside the point. An expert’s opinion on whether the application meets the rules was the point. He was sworn in and went on to testify about the application, including the county code and state law.

In a de novo hearing, the question isn’t whether the board got it wrong. It’s whether the application holds up.


Source: Bunnell City Commission special meeting, Oct. 28, 2026. De novo agreement: Part 1, about 0:44:30. Point of order: Part 2, about 1:39:34 to 1:40:27. Watch the exchange →