Flagler Humane Society: The Two-Year Drama
If you’re just tuning in to the Humane Society storyline, you’ve probably seen it on social media: the city council doesn’t care about animals. They’re heartless. Cruel.
Maybe so.
Or maybe you’ve heard the other version: a shelter that won’t open its books.
We put together two years of meetings between the Flagler Humane Society, the Palm Coast City Council and the Flagler County Commission, in order, on video. Watch it and decide for yourself.
Flagler County Commission
Advocates and activists, several of them former shelter volunteers, take the mic one after another.
They describe crowded kennels, euthanasia decisions, and a dog named Guapo.
A commissioner raises the idea of the county running the shelter itself.
The county administrator answers that the Humane Society is a nonprofit with its own board.
Full meeting: County Commission, Aug. 5, 2024
A former Humane Society volunteer, during public comment.
A county commissioner, then the county administrator.
Palm Coast City Council
The same speakers come to City Hall the next night. Vice Mayor Ed Danko asks what the city pays the Humane Society and what the relationship is.
The answer: it’s a vendor, paid for a service. Council tells staff to set up a joint workshop with the county.
Full meeting: City Council, Aug. 6, 2024
Vice Mayor Ed Danko and city staff.
Joint workshop: County Commission and City Council
Both boards sit down with the Humane Society, and Executive Director Amy Carotenuto walks through the shelter’s history and costs and says it has nothing to hide.
Officials ask about a capital plan, a seat on the Humane Society’s board, and room for a growing county.
At public comment, the Humane Society’s Linda Lester explains a corrected tax filing.
The meeting ends on next steps: a board seat, and next year’s contract.
Full meeting: Joint workshop, Aug. 28, 2024
Amy Carotenuto, executive director, Flagler Humane Society.
A member of the dais asks; Amy Carotenuto answers.
A county commissioner.
Linda Lester, Flagler Humane Society.
Commissioner Greg Hansen, then the commission chair.
Palm Coast City Council
The Humane Society presents to council: no-kill status, a live-release rate near 95 percent, and a city fee it calls far too low.
Council presses on capacity, a capital plan and the bylaws. The mayor raises married couples on the board, and a board member answers him.
The vice mayor says she’s disturbed there’s been no plan to expand.
Full meeting: City Council, Feb. 25, 2025, part 1 · part 2
Amy Carotenuto, executive director, Flagler Humane Society.
Vice Mayor Theresa Pontieri questions Amy Carotenuto.
Vice Mayor Theresa Pontieri questions Amy Carotenuto.
Mayor Mike Norris.
Vince Lyon, Flagler Humane Society board member, during public comment.
Vice Mayor Theresa Pontieri.
Joint workshop: County Commission and City Council
The governments propose new terms for the contract: public bylaws, seats on the board, background checks and more reporting.
Carotenuto says the Humane Society provides what it’s asked for. The board president argues officials on the board would be a conflict of interest, then comes back later in the meeting to welcome them as voting members.
Staff goes back to the Humane Society for a one-year contract.
Full meeting: Joint workshop, April 29, 2025
Amy Carotenuto, executive director, Flagler Humane Society.
Linda Lester, president of the Flagler Humane Society board.
Commissioner Leann Pennington.
Council Member Ty Miller.
Linda Lester, president of the Flagler Humane Society board.
Flagler County Commission workshop
Two months after the joint workshop, county staff comes back with four price tags.
Keep the Humane Society another year: about $320,000.
Let Palm Coast do it: $392,660 a year for dogs and cats only, about $515,000 the first year once sheltering and wildlife are added.
Do it in house: about $456,000, with two officers and a technician.
Build a county shelter with 96 kennels: about $3.8 million, before land.
The board seat is still the sticking point. The Humane Society offers a liaison who meets with it monthly, not a seat at its board meetings.
A commissioner: “It’s not designed to be a closed network. It’s designed to be an open network.”
At public comment, Caroline Johnson of SMART Animal Rescue describes trapping a dozen dogs dumped along Hargrove Grade, with deputies flying drones to help find one.
Other speakers say the shelter is crowded, and ask for an independent audit.
Another commissioner wants the county to take animal control itself: “I do not believe that the Humane Society has to be the sole provider.”
The shelter goes on the county’s list of capital projects. The rest comes back July 2.
Full meeting: County Commission workshop, June 23, 2025
County Administrator Heidi Petito.
A county commissioner.
Caroline Johnson, SMART Animal Rescue, during public comment.
A county commissioner.
Flagler County Commission workshop
The decision meeting isn’t one. Staff still doesn’t have the numbers it asked Palm Coast and the Humane Society for.
The county’s own first-year estimate is about half a million dollars, and a specialized truck takes 14 to 16 months to arrive.
A commissioner: “This is almost designed for failure.”
Another reminds the board that it cut the contract from two years to one so it could make this move, and that a year has gone by.
A third makes the case for one countywide service, run by the county and billed to the cities, the way ambulances are.
The county attorney draws a line worth remembering: animal control and sheltering are “separate and apart.” One is closer to law enforcement. The other is where the animals go.
At public comment, Caroline Johnson of SMART says the course to certify an animal control officer costs under $1,000, and that she already does most of the job, “outside of the criminal aspect of it.”
Another speaker says an animal control officer working under the Humane Society was charged with animal cruelty and given a deferred prosecution. That is her claim.
The direction: prepare another Humane Society contract, use its 120-day exit if needed, and set up a joint meeting with Palm Coast.
Full meeting: County Commission workshop, July 2, 2025
County Administrator Heidi Petito, then a county commissioner.
A county commissioner.
A county commissioner.
The county attorney.
Caroline Johnson, SMART Animal Rescue, during public comment.
Joint workshop: County Commission and City Council
The county weighs moving animal control from the Humane Society to Palm Coast.
One official makes the case for sticking with a single provider. The boards land on a city-county task force to study a second shelter.
Full meeting: Joint workshop, Aug. 6, 2025
A county official.
County staff and Palm Coast officials.
Joint workshop: the cities and the county
The task force reports back. It recommends a second shelter run by a nonprofit, with surrendered pets still going to the Humane Society.
A commissioner recounts why the county pushed for change, including a board seat offered without a seat at the board meetings.
Both boards agree on the second-shelter option.
Full meeting: Joint workshop, Jan. 29, 2026
John Zobler, Palm Coast community development director.
A county commissioner.
The two boards.
Palm Coast budget workshop
The Humane Society tells the city it’s moving to full-cost pricing: from $156 an animal to almost $400, more than double.
Staff says the Humane Society wants donations to go to a capital campaign.
Vice Mayor Theresa Pontieri asks to hold the contract at $156.
Full meeting: Budget workshop, July 14, 2026
Vice Mayor Theresa Pontieri asks; John Zobler, community development director, answers.
Vice Mayor Theresa Pontieri.
Palm Coast budget workshop
A member of the shelter task force tells council the effort has stalled since January, and that a donor has offered ten acres.
Later, Council Member Ty Miller asks where talks stand. Staff says the Humane Society’s tax filings show surpluses and proposes a 10 percent increase instead.
Full meeting: Budget workshop, July 28, 2026
A member of the city-county shelter task force, during public comment.
Council Member Ty Miller asks; city staff answer.
Flagler County Commission
A speaker lists the summer’s cruelty cases: about 25 dogs dumped by a roadside in May and 51 more seized, a puppy dead in a hot garage, two Labradors found dead in a storage unit, a mother and eight puppies in another hot garage. Arrests in each, she says.
Her ask: tougher laws, and the Sheriff’s Office running animal control.
Chair Leann Pennington says Palm Coast let go people cross-trained in animal control, and that, as she understands it, the city manager made the cuts without the council knowing.
Then she asks the county’s lawyers to review the animal abuse ordinances, tethering included, so the Sheriff’s Office has “all the tools in the toolbox.”
A commissioner wants the Sheriff at the coming joint workshop: “Simply saying we don’t want it is not good enough.”
Another, recalling the research behind the current ordinance, agrees the tethering part deserves a second look.
Consensus: the lawyers review the ordinances.
Full meeting: County Commission, Aug. 3, 2026
A county commissioner asks; Chair Leann Pennington answers.
Chair Leann Pennington.
A county commissioner.
Chair Leann Pennington, then a county commissioner.
Joint workshop at City Hall
The governments settle on city land on U.S. 1 for a second shelter, with SMART, the only group that answered the city’s call, to run it.
Carotenuto tells the room the Humane Society isn’t going anywhere. Vice Mayor Theresa Pontieri, the city’s liaison to the Humane Society, says the city was turned away from its board meetings and its budgets, and that she’ll go through the books in person.
Commissioner Andy Dance says there’s room for both.
In the clip “A public record,” Pontieri says the city also asked for the University of Florida consultant’s report and didn’t get it.
Palm Coast Storylines has it now: see the University of Florida report entry.
Full meeting: Joint workshop, Aug. 26, 2026
Amy Carotenuto, executive director, Flagler Humane Society, during public comment.
John Reynolds, during public comment.
Vice Mayor Theresa Pontieri, city liaison to the Humane Society.
Vice Mayor Theresa Pontieri, city liaison to the Humane Society.
Commissioner Andy Dance.
Flagler County Commission
A commissioner raises a veterinarian’s letter about the shelter and calls for more scrutiny than the task force can give.
Full meeting: County Commission, Sept. 2, 2026
A county commissioner.
Flagler County Commission workshop
The morning of the renewal vote, the contract comes up at a workshop.
The year’s shelter money ran out early, staff says. The county moved $30,000 from an underused spay-and-neuter fund to cover it, about $330,000 for the year in all.
Mengel’s message to the Humane Society: live within your budget.
Commissioners focus on the officers. The county swears them in and pays for them, but they work for the Humane Society.
One commissioner says the bad reports come mostly on nights and weekends, and that there’s no patrolling to be seen.
Another says the contract gives the county no clear way to step in when an officer isn’t doing the job, and that animal control has to come under the county, or the county won’t have control.
They ask why the county should pay more per animal than Palm Coast, and what a flat $15,000 for dangerous dogs buys.
At public comment, Amy Carotenuto asks the board to keep animal control with the Humane Society: “A badge and a patrol car do not make someone an effective animal welfare officer.”
“We do not view an animal running at large as a citation waiting to be written,” she says. “We view it as a family pet who has lost its way.”
The board asks for the old and new contracts side by side that evening, and for the Sheriff’s Office to present what it could do.
Full meeting: County Commission workshop, Sept. 14, 2026
Adam Mengel, county administration.
A county commissioner.
A county commissioner.
Amy Carotenuto, executive director, Flagler Humane Society, during public comment.
Flagler County Commission
The Humane Society’s renewal sits on the consent agenda, the list approved without discussion.
After a workshop earlier that day, commissioners pull it. Items are left to address.
The contract runs out Oct. 1, and nothing in it lets the administrator extend it for a month. So the board allows a 30-day extension and sends the contract to the Oct. 5 meeting.
Full meeting: County Commission, Sept. 14, 2026
The commission.
Palm Coast final budget hearing
Asked by Pontieri about the Humane Society contract, staff says $210,000 is the amount in the budget. Council adopts the full budget, 5 to 0.
Full meeting: Final budget hearing, Sept. 23, 2026
Vice Mayor Theresa Pontieri asks; city finance staff answers.
Flagler County Commission
No Humane Society item on the agenda, but near the end of the meeting Mengel raises it.
The contract is coming at the next meeting, he says. Think about the alternative: the county in the animal control business.
At a minimum, he says, the county would have to handle dangerous animals and pets taken in when their owners are arrested, and probably neglect cases too.
Palm Coast’s position at the joint meeting was “a bit of a surprise,” he says. Commissioners recap: the city isn’t taking it, and the Sheriff still owes a presentation.
The plan: put the options side by side with their costs. The Humane Society, the county with an agreement from Palm Coast, or the Sheriff.
Full meeting: County Commission, Oct. 5, 2026
Adam Mengel, interim county administrator, then the commission.
Palm Coast City Council
A speaker at the mic says she obtained a shelter veterinarian’s letter through a public records request.
At Pontieri’s request, council agrees to pursue a contract with SMART, and to look at repaying the $30,000 to $40,000 in vet bills SMART took on when the Humane Society was full.
Full meeting: City Council, Oct. 6, 2026
A resident, during public comment.
Vice Mayor Theresa Pontieri asks the council for consensus.
Palm Coast City Council workshop
Pontieri reports on her review of the Humane Society’s books, which she says she could see only in person, under a non-disclosure agreement.
Her point is the thrift store: about $272,000 from donated goods that, she says, doesn’t show up as profit.
Council Member Ty Miller asks whether federal tax rules require it; she says she isn’t alleging anything illegal. Here is the whole exchange, uncut.
Two days later, the Humane Society answered. Carotenuto told FlaglerLive and the Observer the vice mayor misread how federal tax rules require donated goods to be recorded.
Full meeting: Council workshop, Oct. 13, 2026
Vice Mayor Theresa Pontieri and the City Council.
Palm Coast City Council
At her last council meeting, Vice Mayor Theresa Pontieri answers emails the Humane Society sent the council after her Oct. 13 report.
She says she had to review the books in person, for three hours, with no copies.
While she was there, she says, she asked to see the University of Florida report, and took notes.
She reads from those notes: staffing “well below what is needed to provide appropriate daily care,” capacity concerns “all over this report,” incorrect medical records.
She gives the Humane Society’s answers too. On the medical records: “The FHS said that they have updated their system templates to alleviate that. I don’t know the veracity of that, but that’s what they told me.”
On cats kept in ferret cages, she says, the Humane Society told her it has stopped.
“The Humane Society has responded and they have excuses or defenses to whatever is being alleged against them,” she says. “I’m not going to speak for them.”
“We need the Humane Society to an extent,” she adds. “We cannot stop using their services.”
The contract expired Oct. 8, she says, and runs month to month.
Her ask of the next council: four years of full financials, an audit, and the UF reports, made public, before any renewal.
Council Member Ty Miller agrees, and goes further.
Full meeting: City Council, Oct. 20, 2026
Vice Mayor Theresa Pontieri.
Vice Mayor Theresa Pontieri.
Vice Mayor Theresa Pontieri.
Vice Mayor Theresa Pontieri asks; Council Member Ty Miller answers.
The University of Florida report
The Humane Society asked for it. Maddie’s Million Pet Challenge, a shelter program run with the University of Florida, sent a consultant to the shelter free of charge.
The 39-page report, dated October 2025, was written for the shelter’s leaders, staff and board.
Palm Coast Storylines has obtained a copy.
It opens with the good news: “Motivated leadership and board of directors with a deep desire to continuously improve,” a shelter “serving Flagler County since 1982,” a “high live release rate for many years” and a “Thriving thrift store generating revenue to support FHS’ mission.”
Then the hard part. The consultant counted about 200 animals on site, enough to need 17 animal-care staff.
“On most days, there were only 4 ACA staff members to provide care for dogs and 2 for cats.”
Animals “are typically left without care for 15 hours per day.” The shelter is “over capacity as it is now.”
On the medical side, “surgery capacity is currently the limiting factor to lifesaving,” and a goal of 24 surgeries a day “is not being achieved.”
“Staff were observed leaving anesthetized pets unmonitored.” The disinfectant used in the medical areas is “not effective against” parvovirus and panleukopenia.
The report’s advice on intake: replace “open admission” with “Triaged Coordinated Intake.”
The report describes the shelter at the time of the consultant’s visit, about a year ago.
The Humane Society has posted the full report on its website, with its written answer after each recommendation. The consultant’s findings, its cover letter says, are “unedited.”
Its headline claim: average stays down to 37 days for dogs and 36 for cats, from 81 and 52 at the visit.
On staffing: “We have added additional workers in both animal care departments on higher traffic days and periods of increased workloads.”
On the 15 hours: “Most days there are staff members at FHS until at least 7pm if not later.”
On pets left unmonitored after surgery: “The protocols have been reviewed. During surgery we have always used electronic pulseoxymeters.”
On the disinfectant: “The protocols have been reviewed and updated, now using the Oxivir Five 16 Concentrate,” the product the consultant recommended.
On intake, it pushes back. “We do not want to move to a system of Coordinated Intake that will leave emergency cases without a safe placement option,” it writes, citing four seizure cases from Palm Coast in the past year.
And on pay, a plain admission: “Our current payscale does not meet the Living Wage benchmark for Flagler County.”
Those are the Humane Society’s own accounts. We haven’t been able to check them. Pontieri heard some of the same answers in person; her account is the Oct. 20 entry.
That’s the consultant’s read on the shelter. Now watch the meetings again.
Flagler County Commission
The Humane Society and the county have been without a contract since Oct. 20, acting County Administrator Adam Mengel tells commissioners.
The county’s offer is a pared-down contract: dangerous dogs, animals left behind when their owners are jailed, and neglect cases.
The day before, Executive Director Amy Carotenuto emailed all five commissioners. Cutting animal control, she wrote, “will cost far more in the long run, both financially and in lives.”
Her example: three puppies an officer picked up Oct. 23, after the Humane Society had told the caller it “could no longer respond to stray calls.” She sent a photo of one.

At the meeting, she calls the county’s terms “so much gray area,” and says the Humane Society has had to turn people away over the last few days.
A commissioner asks why it would turn anyone away, if strays are its mission. For 40 years, Carotenuto answers, that was a contracted service.
Another reads from the Humane Society’s tax filing: more than $3 million in revenue, and the line that an animal in need is never turned away.
“I also have to answer to a board of directors,” Carotenuto says.
A commissioner objects to her word for critics, “haters,” and asks everyone to stop the anger.
A motion to extend the old terms through Dec. 31, with a 3 percent raise, stalls when Carotenuto says she can’t speak for her board.
The board approves only a $20,963 budget transfer to close out last year’s bills, 5 to 0.
Commissioner Andy Dance, voting yes: “I don’t know how we got here. This is crazy.”
Animal control goes to a county workshop Nov. 9, with the Sheriff’s Office at the table.
We asked the county for Carotenuto’s letter that morning. It was released while the meeting was still going on.
Full meeting: County Commission, Nov. 2, 2026
Adam Mengel, interim county administrator.
Amy Carotenuto, executive director, Flagler Humane Society.
A county commissioner asks; Amy Carotenuto answers.
A county commissioner asks; Amy Carotenuto answers.
A county commissioner.
Amy Carotenuto and the commission.
Commissioner Andy Dance.
Flagler County Commission workshop
A week later, the Humane Society’s own draft contract is on the table, and Mengel walks commissioners through what worries him.
Under the draft, five or more animals coming in at once count as an “extraordinary circumstance.”
If the Humane Society declines a service, the county would defend it against the claims that follow. “That’s not something we can do,” Mengel says.
There’s also language on what counts as a public record, which the county attorney’s office hasn’t gone over in detail yet.
“I don’t see an agreement happening at today’s meeting,” he says. But the two sides are talking.
Carotenuto says the five-animal clause is meant for hoarding cases and puppy mills, not a cat with a litter of kittens.
On the defense clause: “We just didn’t want to get hung out to dry either.”
She asks for mandatory microchipping, and spay or neuter for animals that keep landing at the shelter.
The county tried for a joint meeting with Palm Coast before the new council takes office. It didn’t happen. “I believe the mayor did not want to meet until he had his new council,” a commissioner says.
Another sums up the mood: “This thing has gone around and around for too long.”
Asked where the shelter’s animals come from, the numbers given at the dais: last year, about 1,200 from Palm Coast and about 800 from the county, wildlife included.
Sheriff Rick Staly is in the audience, and commissioners ask whether his office could take animal control.
A county close to our size that does it spends about $5 million a year, he says. By law his office handles loose livestock, dangerous dogs, and neglect and abuse.
“What I’m not willing to do is be something that cannot be successful because it’s not properly funded.”
At public comment, speakers want county oversight of officers paid with county money, and an independent audit every year.
One speaker says an animal control officer was charged with animal cruelty, and that two dogs were found dead in a storage space with no air conditioning, food or water. Those are her claims.
A volunteer describes deputies and citizens rounding up dumped dogs on a weekend, and a stray turned away at the shelter that morning.
Linda Lester, a Humane Society director, says it has no jurisdiction inside Palm Coast, and that its fees still won’t cover what an animal costs.
Back at the dais, a commissioner on the officers the county appoints: “We swear them in, we pay for them, we have zero oversight into them.”
That, the commissioner says, is how this started: “We had an animal control officer who had an issue with zero oversight.”
And on the Humane Society’s board: “We’re not invited to be on their board. It’s very clear.”
No votes at a workshop. The direction: bring a one-year contract to the next meeting, Nov. 16, with oversight written in.
And once Palm Coast’s new council is seated, a joint meeting on the state money already set aside for a shelter.
Full meeting: County Commission workshop, Nov. 9, 2026
Adam Mengel, interim county administrator.
Amy Carotenuto, executive director, Flagler Humane Society.
A county commissioner.
Sheriff Rick Staly.
A county commissioner asks; Sheriff Rick Staly answers.
A volunteer, during public comment.
A county commissioner.
A county commissioner.
County commissioners and County Attorney Michael Rodriguez.
Flagler County Commission
A week after the workshop, the rewritten contract is on the agenda, added the Friday before.
$350,000 for the year, paid monthly, for what it calls mandatory services: dangerous dogs, cruelty and neglect cases, rabies quarantines, and animals whose owners are jailed or displaced by an emergency.
Everything else, strays included, is at the Humane Society’s discretion, at what the contract calls a reduced level.
Mengel walks through the last-minute changes: the costs of cruelty cases that drag through the courts, and public access to the Humane Society’s records under the contract.
Theresa Pontieri, sworn in to the County Commission the next day, comes to the public mic. Strike the clause that lets the Humane Society call records non-public, she says, add an audit, and sign for six months, not a year.
Of the best option for animal control: “I don’t think the Flagler Humane Society is that.”
Caroline Johnson of SMART: “SMART has no skin in the game as far as animal control at all. We have no desire to take it.”
County Attorney Michael Rodriguez explains the clause covers the Humane Society’s own records, like personnel and finances, not the work it does under the contract.
A commissioner sums up where things stand: “Sheriff doesn’t want it, we don’t want it. Palm Coast doesn’t want it. Nobody wants animal control.”
Another plans to keep “the fire burning,” and says Amendment 3 complicated it.
The vote: one year, through Sept. 30, 2027, with the records clause rewritten to follow state law. Five to nothing.
Tethering, the county attorney says later, will be a chapter in a comprehensive animal control ordinance, if the county takes one on.
Full meeting: County Commission, Nov. 16, 2026
Adam Mengel, interim county administrator.
Theresa Pontieri, county commissioner-elect, during public comment.
Caroline Johnson, SMART Animal Rescue, during public comment.
County Attorney Michael Rodriguez.
A county commissioner.
A county commissioner.
The commission.
That’s the record, in their own words. What you make of it is up to you.
— Johnny Diamond · Palm Coast Storylines