Chair Pennington called the meeting to order, noting the date as October 5, 2026, at 9:00 a.m.
The board stood for the Pledge of Allegiance, followed by a moment of silence for the men and women serving at home and abroad.
Chair Pennington announced several modifications to the agenda: no workshop that day but one scheduled for October 19th; consent item 7F amended to replace an unsigned contract with a signed one; consent item 7G amended to correct schedule references and reflect an increased local match from $10,780 to $21,279.28, inclusive of a scaffolding adjustment; consent item 7H amended to correct a staff report error on miscellaneous services; and item 9A amended to add public comments received after initial publication.
The Chair's announcements were woven into the agenda modifications section.
Chair Pennington noted the absence of a workshop that day and confirmed one would precede the October 19th evening meeting at 5:00 p.m.
No separate recognitions item was discussed; the transcript does not show a standalone recognitions segment distinct from the proclamations.
Four proclamations were adopted.
Commissioner Carney read the Arts and Humanities Month proclamation, with the Flagler County Cultural Council executive director speaking about the council's growth and a new Daytona State College oral history project.
Commissioner Richardson read the Domestic Violence Awareness Month proclamation, with the Family Life Center and Sheriff Staly each speaking to the seriousness of the issue locally, including recent murder-suicides.
Commissioner Dance read the Fire Prevention Week proclamation focused on lithium-ion battery safety, with the Fire Rescue deputy chief elaborating on the theme 'Safe Charging is a Superpower.' Finally, Commissioner Hansen read a proclamation recognizing October 14, 2026 as Charlie Kirk Day of Remembrance, honoring the late conservative commentator who was assassinated in September 2025, with a representative from Florida Voice for the Unborn thanking the board.
The speaker thanked the board for the Arts and Humanities Month proclamation and announced that Daytona State College had agreed to partner with FC3 on a Flagler County oral history project, describing it as a benchmarked archive practice at universities nationwide.
A commissioner offered a family member as one of the first oral history subjects given her long involvement in county economic development.
The speaker thanked the board for the proclamation and for maintaining level funding, described awareness activities including a purple fingernail campaign and a Panera Bread fundraiser, and noted the sixth annual Rise Up Against Domestic Violence conference drew about 50 attendees the previous Friday at Daytona State College.
The Sheriff spoke to the two most dangerous periods for domestic violence victims — during a breakup and within the first two years afterward — and noted that in the past five weeks the county had experienced murder-suicides within both timeframes.
He described his office's dedicated domestic violence investigator and victim advocates and expressed commitment to reducing domestic violence.
A speaker from Flagler County Fire Rescue thanked the board for the proclamation and elaborated on the second consecutive year the National Fire Protection Association's Fire Prevention Week has focused on lithium-ion batteries, noting their prevalence in everyday devices and the fire risk when misused or improperly charged.
Upcoming school and daycare visits to deliver fire safety education were described, along with the Florida Administrative Code fire prevention standards the county enforces.
A speaker thanked the commission for the Charlie Kirk Day of Remembrance proclamation, explaining that Florida Voice for the Unborn and the Christian Family Coalition of Florida had been advocating for such local proclamations after the Florida Legislature failed to pass a statewide recognition.
The speaker quoted Kirk's public statements on abortion and praised the board's action as honoring Kirk's advocacy for conservative and pro-life principles.
No formal presentations separate from the proclamation section appear in the transcript for this agenda item.
The Chair opened the first community outreach period but no speakers came forward.
After a brief pause, the Chair closed the period and moved directly to the consent agenda items.
Commissioner Carney commented on consent item 7B (SMA Healthcare grant), noting she had reviewed the deliverables and found some items under target while others exceeded expectations by hundreds of percentage points; she asked staff to better align deliverables in future agreements but praised SMA's overall service.
Commissioner Dance followed up requesting that replies to board member questions about agenda items be copied to all commissioners.
No items were pulled from the consent agenda.
This item was approved as part of the consent agenda without separate discussion.
This item was approved as part of the consent agenda without separate discussion.
This item was approved as part of the consent agenda without separate discussion.
Approved as part of the consent agenda.
Commissioner Carney raised concerns during board comments on consent (item 5.b) about the alignment of deliverables with the $170,000 grant amount, noting SMA was under target on some deliverables but far exceeded others, and requesting staff improve deliverable alignment in future agreements.
This item was approved as part of the consent agenda without separate discussion.
This item was approved as part of the consent agenda without separate discussion.
This item was approved as part of the consent agenda without separate discussion.
This item was approved as part of the consent agenda as amended, with the unsigned contract replaced by a signed contract per the agenda modification announced at the start of the meeting.
Approved as part of the consent agenda as amended.
During board comments on consent, Commissioner Dance noted he had raised questions about number misalignments in the staff report; staff confirmed corrections had been made, increasing the local match from $10,780 to $21,279.28 inclusive of a scaffolding adjustment.
This item was approved as part of the consent agenda as amended to correct a staff report error regarding the amount for miscellaneous services.
This item was approved as part of the consent agenda without separate discussion.
Health and Human Services Director Joe Hegodus presented a continuation of the RFP process to transition operation of the David I.
Siegel Adult Day Care Center to Therapeutic Assisted Living, noting commissioners had conducted site visits since the last meeting.
Discussion revealed that just before the meeting the applicant had emailed a proposed rate increase from $60/day to $15/hour ($90/day), which the interim procurement manager and County Attorney Michael Rodriguez flagged as a potential bid integrity issue since it changed the pricing basis on which the applicant had been scored highest.
The board unanimously rejected the first-place bid due to the pricing change, then separately directed staff to negotiate with the second-place proposer and return with a recommendation at the next meeting, acknowledging a tight deadline tied to the year-end funding cutoff and 60-day license transfer timeline.
A speaker expressed deep disappointment in the transition process, arguing the county was not honoring the original donation of the property that was intended for elder services.
The speaker contrasted the current county-run program's higher medical staffing level with the proposed operator's more limited staffing, drawing an analogy to paramedic versus EMT capabilities, and said if the facility had to close it would be a shame given the donor's intent.
A speaker argued that adult day care primarily serves caregivers who need respite rather than acute-care patients, countering the previous speaker's concern about staffing levels.
The speaker expressed confidence that the community need exists and can be documented, and urged the board to continue the process rather than close the facility.
Health and Human Services Director Hegodus presented an amended interlocal agreement for cold weather shelter services among Flagler County, Flagler Beach, Palm Coast, and Bunnell, proposing changes including removal of the Church on the Rock as a named site, inclusion of people without heat, an increase in the nightly rate from $1,000 to $1,500, and removal of the 24-night cap in favor of a projected 30-night maximum.
Discussion became substantive when it emerged the shelter operator (Sheltering Tree) had lost its church site and staff proposed the new Expo Hall at the fairgrounds as a replacement, prompting concerns from Commissioner Dance about due process for existing fairground users such as 4-H.
The board ultimately split the matter into two votes: unanimously approving the amended ILA, then approving in principle the use of the Expo Hall for cold weather sheltering with Emergency Management Director Jonathan Lord directed to meet with all relevant stakeholders and return with a formal facility use agreement at the next meeting.
A speaker from the Sheltering Tree board described the organization's 17-year history operating cold weather shelters in Flagler County, first at a Bunnell Methodist church and then at Church on the Rock.
The shelter uses about 30 volunteers each night and no paid county staff; the speaker proposed that if the board was concerned about the $1,500 rate, it could start at $1,000 with any overage split among the four jurisdictions as the ILA already provides, and offered to meet with any stakeholders the board wished.
County Attorney Rodriguez explained the board's appellate role, limited to reviewing whether the Planning and Development Board's decision denying a variance for a pump house at Pelican Lane was supported by competent substantial evidence, accorded due process, and observed essential requirements of law.
Growth Management staff Simone Kenny walked through a lengthy chronology dating to February 2025 involving multiple variance applications, split planning board votes, a prior BOCC appeal upheld unanimously, a remand, and ultimately a 4-2 planning board denial in August 2026 on the grounds that the requested 9-foot-7-inch pump house height was not the minimum relief necessary.
The applicant argued the height was required for pool equipment functionality and that his application had not been given a fair hearing, while neighbors presented detailed arguments that the planning board properly weighed the evidence, that conventional equipment could fit within 4 feet, and that the engineer's letter submitted day-of provided no site-specific necessity.
The board denied the appeal, affirming the planning board's decision, with one dissenting vote.
The property owner at the site on Pelican Lane presented a 10-point rebuttal arguing the process had dragged on for nearly 20 months without resolution; that no height variance was ever requested because the proposed 9-foot-7-inch structure was always below the 12-foot accessory structure allowance; that the planning board's 4-foot condition was arbitrary since no code provision mandates it; that a professional engineering opinion letter had been obtained as requested; and that neighboring properties have larger unpermitted structures.
The hardship was maintained to be not self-created but arising from the lot's undersized status under current zoning.
A neighbor speaking on behalf of several adjacent property owners argued that the planning board had properly weighed all evidence and offered viable alternatives, that the originally granted variances eliminating the 25-foot streetside setback were already extraordinary, and that the 4-foot height condition was a reasonable compromise the neighborhood accepted.
The engineering letter submitted the day of the August planning board meeting was said not to evaluate the specific equipment, state a need for enclosure, or identify minimum required dimensions, and the pump manufacturer was noted as not requiring enclosure.
The speaker urged the board to uphold the planning board's denial.
A neighbor speaking on behalf of another property owner argued that the applicant has had full due process over more than 20 months and that the engineering letter contained general assumptions without site-specific necessity findings.
The speaker contended that the applicant's chosen pool equipment is non-conventional and that conventional equipment could fit within 4 feet, and asked the board to end the repeated applications by upholding the denial.
A neighbor speaking on behalf of another property owner argued that four planning board members who had voted in favor of the variance across different meetings had each missed at least one hearing and therefore had not heard all the testimony and evidence.
The three members who consistently supported the 4-foot condition attended all meetings, included two general contractors who know the condition is feasible, and the applicant's refusal to consider relocating the pump house to the rear of the property was said to undermine the hardship claim.
Interim County Administrator Adam Mengel distributed budget infographics and wallet cards for commissioners to share with the public.
He reported 11 executive search firms had been contacted for the county administrator search, with nine responses and estimated costs of $20,000–$50,000, and noted a staff meeting with two firms the following week.
He raised committee assignment timing, legislative priorities scheduling (aiming for two workshops and a joint delegation meeting in January), the meeting schedule restructuring proposal, and sought consensus on whether to invite BikeMan organization to present on the essential-public-service question before any facility use decision.
He also flagged the pending Humane Society contract renewal and animal control service structure questions, and provided a brief update on the Waste Pro permitting confusion at DEP, noting staff was at least partly responsible and that an amnesty day was targeted for January.
The Administrator updated the board that 11 executive search firms had been contacted, nine had responded, and estimated costs ranged from $20,000 to $50,000.
HR staff would meet with two firms the following week to narrow down proposals, with a plan to bring the item back to the board in November.
Commissioner Carney asked for an update on Waste Pro and progress toward an amnesty day for household hazardous waste.
The Administrator explained that some of the DEP permitting confusion for Waste Pro's small quantity generator program was caused by county staff, and that he planned to contact the DEP Jacksonville office to help move Waste Pro's permit renewal forward; amnesty day remains on track for January.
County Attorney Rodriguez clarified that before the county could allow any organization to use public property without a competitive bid process, the board must first determine that the organization meets a statutory essential-public-service standard.
He noted BikeMan had not yet made or justified such a request, and suggested staff advise them of the threshold they must clear before the county can even consider a no-bid facility arrangement.
The Administrator reported that the CFO's office indicated the records previously requested by the county do not exist and that the CFO would begin charging for the records search.
With board consensus, a letter withdrawing the request was planned, framing it as a way to maintain a constructive relationship with the CFO going forward.
County Attorney Rodriguez briefly reported that the City of Bunnell accepted the county's appeal of the landfill decision and was planning a special meeting to hear all eight appeals individually, with the county's appeal based on comprehensive plan grounds.
He also reminded commissioners that sunshine law applies to commissioners-elect from election day through swearing-in, cautioning against discussing committee assignments with any newly elected commissioner during that interval.
County Attorney Rodriguez reported that the City of Bunnell accepted the county's appeal of a landfill-related decision and was scheduling a special meeting to hear all eight pending appeals individually, with the county's appeal grounded in comprehensive plan arguments.
He explained that if Bunnell affirms even one of the eight appeals, that creates a development order that then allows the county to proceed to circuit court if it chooses.
The Chair opened the second community outreach period.
No speakers came forward and the period was immediately closed.
Commissioner Richardson reported on the FC3 (Flagler County Cultural Council) annual meeting, praising the significant growth, the quality of their annual report booklet, and advocating for continued mural expansion; she also corrected a prior statement about Arbitron ratings, clarifying that Flagler County is too small a market to be rated.
Commissioner Carney raised the need for red-line documents when contracts are updated, asking staff to provide them when feasible.
Commissioner Dance recognized a Northeast Florida Regional Council staff member present and noted the recent regional council meeting held at the Nexus Center.
Administrator Mengel raised a pending public records request to the CFO's office, noting CFO staff had indicated the records do not exist and would be charging for the search; with board consensus he will withdraw the request with a letter acknowledging the records are not present.
Commissioner Richardson reported on a well-attended FC3 annual meeting, praising the organization's growth under its current leadership and the quality of its annual report booklet.
She advocated for continuing to find spaces for more murals, citing their positive community impact.
Commissioner Carney asked why red-line comparison documents are not routinely provided when amended contracts come before the board, noting she had manually compared two Humane Society contracts and found major differences.
County Attorney Rodriguez acknowledged it is feasible when the county holds a word-processing version of the prior contract and said he would work on a practical comparison method going forward.