The Chair called the meeting to order at 5:02 PM on November 16, 2026, and led the Pledge of Allegiance, followed by a moment of silence for men and women serving in the military.
The Chair announced that the agenda had been amended to add the application of Timothy Conner for reappointment to the Planning and Development Board, along with an amended staff report and updated options for the board's consideration.
The Chair announced the addition of an evaluation summary attachment to the county attorney's annual review and salary increase item.
The Chair announced the addition of a new general business agenda item — the FY 2026-27 agreement with the Flagler Humane Society for Animal Control Services.
The Chair announced the evening's agenda modifications and then introduced the Fire Rescue Life Saving Awards presentation.
No additional formal announcements were made beyond those already covered under agenda modifications.
Fire Chief recognized a firefighter-paramedic for a cardiac arrest save in which she and her partner performed CPR for approximately 30 minutes, achieving return of spontaneous circulation.
The Chief also received an award from the Knights of Columbus.
The board then recognized outgoing Commissioner Greg Hansen for his ten years of service, with each commissioner offering personal remarks about his contributions, particularly to the Hammock area, and presenting him with a commemorative gift.
No proclamations were presented at this meeting.
The Chair noted there was no presentation listed and the meeting moved on to community outreach.
During the community outreach period, two speakers addressed the board regarding beach erosion and coastal management issues for Reach Three of the northern barrier island.
One speaker made a detailed legal and ecological argument that the DEP's near-shore rock habitat designation was being improperly used to block beach renourishment, constituting a de facto managed retreat and an unconstitutional taking.
A second speaker compared Alternatives 2 and 3 from a Moffatt review, noting cost differences, and urged the board to contest DEP and FWC overreach through staff, while also outlining a forthcoming legislative package involving the Army Corps of Engineers.
A speaker argued that FDEP's designation of near-shore rock in Reach Three as habitat is ecologically unimportant compared to the upland coastal preservation area destroyed by erosion, and that DEP's rules as applied amount to weaponizing the habitat designation against upland development protection.
The speaker argued that both the county and DEP have an obligation under Florida Statute 161 to balance marine habitat, upland habitat, and storm damage protection, and that DEP is effectively advocating for managed retreat and an unconstitutional taking.
A speaker distributed a comparison sheet contrasting Alternative 2 (a hybrid dredge-and-truck distribution approach at $5.2 million per year) with Alternative 3 (a full dredge at $6.2 million per year), arguing that Alternative 2 must be pursued immediately because further delay will result in continued erosion.
A forthcoming legislative package was described that would extend Army Corps of Engineers eligibility to additional Flagler County shoreline and inland watershed areas, with the Army Corps noted as having already responded positively.
Commissioners were asked whether they had questions about consent items; each indicated they had no items to pull, with Commissioner Dance noting staff had already answered his questions.
No items were pulled from the consent agenda.
Approved on consent agenda without separate discussion.
Approved on consent agenda without separate discussion.
Approved on consent agenda without separate discussion.
Approved on consent agenda without separate discussion.
Approved on consent agenda without separate discussion.
Approved on consent agenda without separate discussion.
Approved on consent agenda without separate discussion.
Approved on consent agenda without separate discussion.
Approved on consent agenda without separate discussion.
General Services Director Dan Nicholas presented a request to remove approximately a dozen projects from the Capital Improvement Plan that had been rescoped or were no longer needed, while adding two new projects: replacement of carpeting on the first floor of the Tax Collector's office following sewage backup damage, and funding for a four-phase field restoration plan at Wadsworth Park.
Commissioner Dance noted he had received clarification about rescoping of the Lehigh Trail, with the director explaining that spot repairs and asphalt work had been completed on the eastern end of the trail to address hazardous conditions.
Growth Management staff presented the process for filling two expiring Planning and Development Board seats, noting that twelve new applications had been received in addition to the two incumbents seeking reappointment.
The board debated whether to reappoint the incumbents or open the seats to all applicants, ultimately opting to run a scored ballot including all fourteen candidates.
After tabulating results, the board appointed an applicant to the at-large seat with a waiver of the homestead requirement, and after two rounds of voting, appointed Thaddeus Crowe with a waiver of the unincorporated residency requirement on a 4-1 vote.
Several applicants introduced themselves before the vote, and multiple members of the public offered endorsements of specific candidates.
A speaker described eight tie votes on the board over nearly two years, arguing that the difficulty was symptomatic of a stale board and advocating that the commission appoint new members with fresh perspectives.
A speaker strongly endorsed the appointment of Thaddeus Crowe, citing his 40 years of professional planning experience, 15 years as a planning director, certification as a professional planner, prior nine-year service on the county's planning board, and specific contributions to Flagler County including the A1A scenic highway overlay standards and the Hammock Visioning process.
The speaker argued that Crowe's experience would elevate the quality of board deliberations during a period of accelerating development pressure.
A speaker quoted the land development code provision requiring that applicants with experience in the field of planning and zoning receive special preference, and argued that Flagler County has a unique opportunity to place a highly credentialed planning professional on the board at a time of critical growth, particularly in the Hammock area.
A speaker endorsed both Thaddeus Crowe and another applicant, arguing that community organizing experience and civic engagement are as valuable as formal credentials, and that Flagler County needs fresh perspectives on its planning board particularly given the passage of Amendment 3.
The other applicant was praised for her work during a local emergency and her familiarity with county regulations and community conflicts.
Airport Director Roy Sieger and a consultant from ESA presented Working Paper No.
2 of the Flagler Executive Airport Master Plan Update, covering facility requirements for the next 20 years.
The presentation highlighted that the airport is currently at approximately 91% of capacity — well past the FAA's 60% planning threshold — and that the recommended solution is construction of a 3,200-foot parallel runway to separate training aircraft from corporate jets, a significantly smaller footprint than the 5,000-foot runway previously contemplated on the Airport Layout Plan.
Commissioners questioned the relationship between training aircraft demand and obligations under FAA grant assurances, the noise impact of expanded capacity, and whether this planning document committed the board to any construction, with staff and the consultant clarifying that actual construction would require separate board approval of grants.
The board reached consensus to submit Working Paper No.
2 to FDOT and the FAA.
A speaker expressed support for the airport as an economic asset but raised concern that expanding capacity will generate noise levels incompatible with the community's residential growth trajectory toward 250,000 population.
Drawing on personal experience with noise mitigation programs at another major airport, the speaker warned the board that legal challenges and expensive mitigation obligations could follow if community noise concerns are not addressed proactively.
Interim County Administrator Mengel presented the results of the County Attorney's annual performance evaluation, noting that Michael Rodriguez received a score of 3.78, which under the county's merit policy would correspond to a 1.5% increase.
Chair Pennington proposed setting the salary at $205,000 and outlined four goals she discussed with Rodriguez, including involvement in the Land Development Regulations rewrite, efficiency improvements in the legal office, updates on ordinances in process at regular meetings, and a new commissioner orientation guide.
Other commissioners praised Rodriguez's responsiveness and work on issues including the landfill litigation and board Sunshine Law compliance training.
Interim County Administrator Mengel presented a last-minute FY 2026-27 animal control services agreement with the Flagler Humane Society for $350,000, explaining that late revisions had been made to Section 5 to address cost recovery for extraordinary circumstances such as cruelty cases tied to court proceedings, and to Section 12B to clarify county and public access to public records.
The board discussed the scope of mandatory services, the definition of non-public records, the possibility of a shorter term, and the ongoing need for a joint meeting with the City of Palm Coast.
County Attorney Rodriguez clarified that Section 12E was not intended to withhold records subject to Chapter 119 and proposed modifying the language accordingly.
The agreement was approved for a one-year term with that modification to Section 12E.
A speaker urged the board to strike Section 12E of the Humane Society contract to remove any discretion over non-public record designations, arguing that public records obligations should be governed strictly by statute.
The speaker also recommended limiting the contract to six months rather than one year to maintain urgency in developing a better long-term animal control solution, and stated that the Flagler Humane Society is not the right long-term provider for animal control services.
A speaker argued that a CPA conducting the Humane Society's books is functionally equivalent to an external audit and that questioning those financials is unfounded, expressing frustration with the prolonged dispute over animal control.
The speaker endorsed a one-year contract with a cost-of-living increase, criticizing a six-month term as counterproductive.
A speaker drew a distinction between an independent audit and a CPA paid by the entity being reviewed, noting that many Florida counties require independent audits of organizations receiving public funds.
The speaker called for consolidating all animal control countywide under a single authority — either the Sheriff or a county department — to eliminate jurisdictional confusion that results in some animals being picked up and others left behind on adjacent streets, and asked the commission to follow up on requests made over two years ago for tougher animal protection ordinances.
A speaker described unanswered calls about aggressive dogs and difficulty retrieving a held animal after hours.
The speaker argued that allowing owners to retrieve their animals promptly after hours would reduce costs for both the county and pet owners, and urged better county oversight of the animal control function.
A speaker representing a local animal rescue organization clarified that the group has no intention of taking over the animal control function and no competition with the Humane Society, emphasizing that the goal of all parties should be the welfare of animals.
Recent fieldwork trapping severely fearful stray dogs was described, with the speaker stressing the importance of having animal control services regardless of which entity provides them.
OMB Manager Brian Eichinger read the title of a resolution to amend the FY 2026-27 budget by $130,559,368 as part of the annual carry-forward process.
No questions were raised by the board, there was no public comment, and the resolution was approved.
Growth Management staff presented a Future Land Use Map amendment for a 1.01-acre parcel on County Road 2006 West, seeking a change from Agriculture and Timberlands to Residential Low Density/Rural Estate.
Staff explained that the parcel was rendered unbuildable by an illegal lot split in 2005 made by a previous owner, and that the amendment would enable the current owners — who purchased the land unaware of the problem — to build a single-family home near Crescent Lake.
The Planning and Development Board had unanimously recommended approval, and there was no opposition at the public hearing.
Staff presented the companion quasi-judicial rezoning for the same 1.01-acre parcel, proposing a change from AC Agricultural to MH-1 Rural Mobile Home District, which has a minimum lot size of one acre and would bring the nonconforming parcel into conformance.
No ex-parte communications were disclosed, there were no questions from the board, and no public comment was received.
The rezoning was approved with the condition that development not commence until the effective date of the future land use amendment, approximately 31 days hence.
Staff presented a Future Land Use Map amendment for 17.6 acres at Sawgrass Road near the Flagler County Fairgrounds, seeking a change from Agriculture and Timberlands to Industrial, while leaving 9.9 acres of wetlands in Conservation.
The property has been used for site development storage of fill dirt, topsoil, and crushed concrete — a nonconforming use in the agricultural district — and the amendment would bring it into conformance.
Commissioner Dance raised concerns about the breadth of permitted uses in the industrial zoning district, particularly near the fairgrounds, and discussed with the applicant's attorney and County Administrator whether restrictions should be addressed through a future Land Development Code amendment rather than through this application.
The Planning and Development Board had unanimously recommended approval.
Staff presented the companion quasi-judicial rezoning for the same Sawgrass Road property, rezoning 17.6 acres from Agricultural to Industrial while retaining the 9.9 acres of wetlands in the Agricultural district, which is the only zoning compatible with the Conservation future land use designation.
Staff noted that while the use would be brought into conformance, a couple of existing structures would remain nonconforming as to setbacks.
Commissioner Dance disclosed a prior conversation with the property owner about conforming the existing nonconforming buildings.
No public comment was received, and the rezoning was approved.
The Interim County Administrator noted upcoming events including a legislative priorities workshop planned for December, a swearing-in ceremony the following day for two commissioners, and confirmed receipt of correspondence from a developer regarding the Bull Creek headwaters purchase, which is under review for the DEP triage process.
He also thanked Commissioner Hansen for his service.
County Attorney Rodriguez thanked the board for the evaluation and announced that he is working on a resolution to establish a repeat domestic abuse registry, coordinating with IT on the technical and financial requirements.
He updated the board on two litigation matters: a federal court appeal of a cell tower denial in the Mondex, which is on an expedited schedule heading toward mediation and summary judgment; and a complaint filed in the Northern District of Florida that has been stricken twice by the court for procedural deficiencies and has not been properly served.
He also confirmed that an alcohol sales ordinance is on the agenda for the first December meeting and that dog tethering provisions will be part of a future comprehensive animal control ordinance.
During the final community outreach period, three speakers addressed the board.
One speaker urged the county attorney to protect veterans' disability, senior citizen, and low-income homeowner tax deductions as the county implements Amendment 3.
A second speaker raised concerns about the future use of county-owned properties, including the senior center building on Belter, arguing that such assets risk becoming idle or falling into developer hands, and offered a community redevelopment group to assist.
The newly appointed planning board member thanked the commission for the appointment.
A speaker urged the county attorney to ensure that as Amendment 3 is implemented, the county preserves existing tax deductions for veterans with disabilities, senior citizens, and low-income homeowners, noting that other Florida counties and municipalities are already taking steps to carry those protections forward in their fee and tax structures.
A speaker expressed concern that the senior center building on Belter Road and other county-owned properties will fall idle and risk being transferred to developers, as has happened with other county assets in the past, and offered the services of a community redevelopment group ready to manage any underutilized county properties for neighborhood benefit.
Historical examples including the old courthouse and various community center buildings were cited as evidence of a recurring pattern of poor asset stewardship.
Commissioner Richardson reported on the Value Adjustment Board, the canvassing board process, and a successful FC3 festival.
Commissioner Hansen offered a farewell reflection and urged the board to watch the legislative challenge being mounted against DEP's interpretation of coastal habitat designation rules, noting that the effort had backing from state senators and representatives and aimed to establish in law the right of coastal communities to protect their beaches.
Commissioner Carney reported on the library board, the canvassing board, a Veterans Day celebration, and participation in an economic development kickoff meeting for a prospect.
Commissioner Dance raised the idea of alternate planning board members to avoid tie votes, which the County Attorney addressed by advising that affirmative motions failing on a tie constitute a denial, eliminating the need for alternates.
Various commissioners also noted the broken water station at Hidden Trails Park is being replaced and discussed the possibility of a food or can drive.
Before the meeting · Item 8.e · Nov 16, 2026
The Board first took this up at its November 9 workshop and asked staff for a draft agreement for this meeting. Staff calls the result a complete rewrite of the previous agreement. p.340
“constitutes a complete rewrite of the previous Agreement”
Funding is limited to $350,000 a year, paid in equal monthly installments of $29,166.67 and retroactive to October 1, 2026. p.340
“funding is limited to $350,000 per year”
The term runs from October 1, 2026 to September 30, 2027. It can be renewed for up to two more one-year terms if both parties agree in writing and the Board approves. p.342
“shall terminate on September 30, 2027”
Mandatory Services are dangerous dog cases, animal neglect cases, the ten-day rabies quarantine and impoundment, sheltering for animals whose owner is detained or incarcerated, and sheltering for displaced residents during a local state of emergency. p.342
“Sheltering services for animals whose owner is detained or incarcerated by law enforcement.”
Additional Services, such as sheltering and adopting out strays and surrendered animals, are limited. The agreement says there is not enough funding to provide them to every animal for the whole term, intends a reduced level, and lets the Humane Society accept or cease them based on county funding. It must give the county advance written notice when it declines an animal. p.343
“absolute operational discretion to accept or cease the provision of Additional Services”
An extraordinary circumstance now means 25 or more animals from a single location or owner. The cover memo says the number was five. p.340
“changed from five or more animals to 25 or more animals”
The agreement does not require the Humane Society to respond to extraordinary circumstances. It may ask the Board for help, which the Board reviews case by case. p.345
“case-by-case basis by the Board of County Commissioners”
Either side can end the agreement without cause on 90 days' written notice. p.346
“terminated, in whole or in part, without cause by either PARTY upon ninety (90)”
Staff writes that the passage of Amendment 3 substantially changes the county's approach, that the county still funds the bulk of Humane Society operations and far exceeds the share the municipal partners provide, and that further service level cuts are likely as the FY 2027-28 budget is prepared. p.340
“further service level cuts are likely”
The packet also attaches the FY 2025-26 contract and two signed amendments (attachments 2 to 4 on the cover memo's list). Palm Coast Storylines has not compared them with this agreement, so no change from last year's amount is stated here.
Source: the Nov 16, 2026 agenda packet (page numbers link to the page); background written from the packet by Palm Coast Storylines. Full packet →