Palm Coast
storylines...

Independent Reporting · Palm Coast, Florida
Published
Hargrove Grade  ·  The Paper

An Asphalt Factory: Use Not Permitted


At the end of Hargrove Grade, where the industrial park runs out of road, there is a six-acre lot with a rail spur beside it and a construction company’s yard on it. The owner has applied to put an asphalt plant there.

Palm Coast’s Land Development Code keeps a in the city. Asphalt manufacturing plants are on it, with hog farms, oil refineries and deep well injection of waste.

The same section leaves a door open. A use on the list may be permitted by a super majority vote of the City Council, after the planning board makes a recommendation. That is four votes out of five.

The door: a use on the list may be permitted by a super majority vote of the City Council after the planning board recommends, for or against. Four of five votes.

Staff says this appears to be the first application anyone has made under that section.

What they ask for

The owner is ACCI Ventures. It bought the property in June of 2023 and uses it for heavy construction and excavation. The land is zoned heavy industrial and the future land use is industrial, and neither would change.

The applicant’s attorney describes an asphalt plant in general terms: aggregate and sand feed systems, conveyors, a drying and mixing drum, asphalt cement storage, emissions control, silos and a loading area.

The applicant's concept plan, with the plan's lot area table: lot 252,498.59 square feet; proposed plant area 34,969.51; existing buildings 16,889.98; existing concrete, asphalt and millings 95,757.81; total impervious area about 147,617 (58.5 percent)

The packet says how it would run. Production would happen at night, roughly nine in the evening to five in the morning, and not every day. A batch is made to order, then the plant shuts down, and output is expected to run 250 to 300 tons on a typical day, which the applicant puts at 10 to 15 truckloads.

A 24-hour dial with the traffic study's 6 pm to 7 am truck window and the applicant's 9 pm to 5 am plant hours

The first year starts near 50,000 tons, about 2,000 to 2,500 truckloads. The plan is to grow to between 200,000 and 300,000 tons a year, depending on growth, which is 8,000 to 15,000 truckloads a year.

A plant making 300 tons a day, every day of the year, would reach about 110,000 tons, or 4,400 to 5,500 loads. The packet does not say how a year gets from there to 200,000 or more.

The truck counts are our arithmetic. The applicant’s figures say 10 to 15 truckloads a day for 250 to 300 tons, which works out to about 20 to 25 tons a load. They count only asphalt going out, not the stone and sand coming in, or the employees.

The numbers that don’t match

The packet is more than sixty pages, from the applicant, the applicant’s engineers and the City. On several basics, it gives more than one answer.

Jobs. The applicant’s attorney says the plant would create 125 to 150 local jobs. A later memo from the same attorney says more than fifty new positions. The traffic study counts ten additional employees.

Three cards: 125 to 150 local jobs (applicant's attorney, July 16 letter, p. 26); more than 50 new positions (Oct. 8 memo, p. 29); 10 additional employees (traffic study, Sept. 25, p. 37)

Trucks. The applicant’s answers to neighbors say ten to fifteen truckloads a day. The traffic study counts forty dump trucks through the day and a hundred more between six at night and seven in the morning, about three hundred trips in all, counting employees.

Three cards: 10 to 15 truckloads a day (applicant's answers to neighbors, Sept. 30, p. 61); 40 plus 100 dump trucks (traffic study, p. 37); 300 trips a day, employees included (traffic study, Table 1, p. 37)

Acres. The staff report says five and ninety-three hundredths. The concept plan’s table says five and eight-tenths. The traffic study describes a 2.34-acre site.

Three cards: 5.93 acres (staff report, p. 3); 5.80 acres, 252,499 square feet (concept plan lot area table, p. 22); 2.34 acres (traffic study, p. 37)

The nearest plant. The applicant’s attorney says the nearest existing asphalt plant is nearly thirty miles away. The traffic study calls this an expansion of an existing asphalt plant to the south.

And the process. The application, the applicant’s letters and the survey affidavit call this a special exception. Staff’s report says it is not one.

Two cards: Special exception (the applicant's description, application form and letters, pp. 13 and 24 to 26); Not a special exception application, a modified process (staff report, p. 2)

None of this has to mean anything is wrong. What it does mean is that the planning board will be asked to recommend on a record that doesn’t agree with itself.

What staff says, and doesn’t

Staff’s report walks through five findings the Code requires. On the first, whether the plant is contrary to the public interest, staff writes that it may be, because the Code lists the use as not permitted. Staff adds that if the plant is approved, a technical site plan would follow, and that outside agencies, including the state’s environmental agency, would review parts of it.

On a different point, staff writes that the lot sits at the end of an industrial park, beside a railroad, in heavy industrial zoning, and calls it, in staff’s opinion, the most likely place in the city for this kind of use. On the closest homes, staff says the nearest residential zoning is a tract in Palm Coast Park to the north, and that the tract has a fair amount of wetlands.

What staff does not say is whether the board should approve. The report says staff was instructed not to give a recommendation, by the Interim Community Development Director, after a discussion with the City Attorney.

The applicant’s attorney had asked for one. His memo to staff says the board and Council will rely on the City’s technical review and requests a recommendation, with the reasons for any criterion staff finds unmet.

Staff also says about an acre and a quarter on the south side of the lot was cleared without a permit, seen on aerial photos, and that the site would have to be restored. The applicant’s letter calls the request mainly an addition of equipment, without substantial alteration of the land.

The City’s public permit search lists , from 2006 to June of 2016. The owners named on them are earlier companies. Not one names the current owner or American Civil Construction.

They cover a silo demolition, a chemical blending company, added laboratory space, a trucking company’s dispatch office and truck repair shop, and a loading dock with a retaining wall. The search shows no permit that mentions recycling, land clearing or storing materials. It covers building permits only, so Palm Coast Storylines has asked the City for the rest of its records on the lot.

What the vote decides

A yes from the planning board is a recommendation, not a permit. If Council approves, the result is a development order that lasts twelve months, with one twelve-month extension. It does not authorize site work.

Four gates in order: planning board, City Council, technical site plan, outside agencies

To build, the owner would have to file a technical site plan, and that is where lighting, sound, water use, air quality and chemical storage are reviewed. Staff names three outside agencies: the water management district, the state environmental agency and the health department.

Florida has a that a plant can register under. The rule sets a ceiling of 600,000 tons a year for the kind of plant described here, a limit on dust and smoke, and a stack test. It says nothing about distance from homes, and a separate state rule against objectionable odor applies to any source. Whether this plant would use the general permit is not in the packet.

Who has spoken before, and who decides

The owner of 77 Hargrove Grade has spoken to this board before. In February, in public comment at the board’s hearing on a concrete plant at 56 Hargrove Grade, he asked the board to approve it. He said he buys that company’s concrete in other cities. That request .

He said his dump trucks and tractor-trailers use Hargrove Grade every day with no issues, and that he did not know what residents on the road were experiencing from his trucks. He said Palm Coast is growing west, and that more industrial land west of the railroad will connect to Hargrove Grade. And he said that in 35 years in the business, he has found concrete companies, asphalt plants and steel manufacturers to be community partners.

What the packet does not contain

At the September 29 neighborhood meeting, attendees asked about air emissions and odor. The applicant’s attorney recorded the applicant’s answers in a letter to the City the next day. It says the plant uses a drum-mix process with a baghouse filter, and natural gas to heat and dry the aggregate.

It acknowledged that asphalt production has an odor. It said the plant would need a mass-emissions permit and would have to meet federal, state and local permitting requirements, that daily production would run only three to four hours, and that its volatile organic compound emissions are relatively low. It also said the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency generally considers modern asphalt plants low risk.

Here is what the packet does not contain. An air permit application. The size of any equipment, or the height of a stack. Any measurement of odor, noise or dust.

The distance from the lot to the nearest school, or the nearest city wellfield. The City’s Comprehensive Plan says an industrial use’s closeness to wellfields shall be considered. The packet doesn’t say how close.

It also leaves out the distance to the nearest home. Palm Coast Storylines to find out. The nearest home is a little over a mile east of the lot. Within two miles there are more than 1,700 residential properties.

What other studies say about is at the bottom of this story, with links to the reports.

Both sides, at their strongest

The applicant’s strongest point: the lot is already zoned for heavy industry, sits at the end of an industrial park beside a rail line, and staff itself calls it the most likely place in the city for this use.

The other side’s strongest point: the Code lists the use as one that can create nuisances and adverse effects on neighboring land, staff finds it may be contrary to the public interest, and the packet does not give the distance to a home, a school or a wellfield.

The board votes Wednesday. The Council decides later, and it needs four.

The packet: Planning and Land Development Regulation Board, Nov. 18, 2026, item D.4, AR 6785 (PDF)


— Johnny Diamond  ·  Palm Coast Storylines

The list of uses not permitted


Section 3.01.06 of the Land Development Code, “Uses not permitted in the city,” names uses the city does not allow. Asphalt manufacturing plants are on it. So are animal feed lots and livestock operations, bottle clubs, bulk fuel depots or oil refineries, data centers, deep well injection of waste products, dog farms, and hog and poultry farms.

The section adds that a listed use may be permitted by a super majority vote of the City Council, after a recommendation from the planning board. Staff’s report says this appears to be the City’s first application under the section.

The wording is the version the Council adopted Oct. 20, 2026, as the City’s council packet and draft minutes record it.


Source: City of Palm Coast Council packet and draft minutes, Oct. 20, 2026 (Ordinance 2026-10, amending the Unified Land Development Code); staff report, planning board packet item D.4, pp. 1 to 2.

Fourteen permits at 77 Hargrove Grade


The City of Palm Coast’s public permit search, searched by address on Nov. 17, 2026, lists 14 permits at 77 Hargrove Grade, issued from 2006 to 2016. The owners named on them are Matschel of Flagler Inc. (2006 to 2011) and Quality Experts Transportation LLC (2015 to 2016). None names ACCI Ventures or American Civil Construction.

2016 — interior and roof demolition (March); remodel of the office building with a new roof and windows (June).

2015 — trucking company dispatching occupancy (January); an auto repair shop occupancy, cancelled; loading dock and 150-foot retaining wall (September); truck repair shop occupancy (October).

2011 — a 32-by-179-foot open metal structure with a composite roof (July); occupancy for a chemical blending and packaging company (August).

2010 — relocation of three plastic storage tanks and one stainless steel tank (May).

2006 to 2008 — fire alarm (2006); demolition of a silo (April 2007); fence and landscaping (November 2007); laboratory space added to the building and a fire sprinkler (2008).

The search shows no permit that mentions recycling, land clearing or storing materials. It covers building permits found by address; site work may be filed in another City system. A search of 80 Hargrove Grade, which the applicant also owns, returned no permits.


Source: City of Palm Coast public permit search, palmcoast.gov/building/search, address search run Nov. 17, 2026. Palm Coast Storylines has asked the City Clerk for permit, clearing and code records on the lot.

How far is the nearest home?


The packet gives no distance from the lot to a home. Palm Coast Storylines measured it from the county’s parcel records, from the edge of the lot at 77 Hargrove Grade to the edge of each parcel.

The nearest home: about 1.06 miles (5,600 feet, or 1.7 kilometers), to the east. It is a single-family home zoned SFR-3, on land the City designates Residential.

Within about 1.9 miles (9,800 feet, or 3 kilometers): 1,778 residential parcels. That is 1,650 single-family, 120 small multifamily, 6 attached homes and 2 large multifamily parcels. A multifamily parcel can hold more than one home, so this counts parcels, not households.

Neighbors that are not homes:

71 Hargrove Grade (light manufacturing) and 6 Hargrove Lane (self storage) touch the lot. 15 Railside Way (flex space) is about 100 feet (30 meters) away, 64 Hargrove Grade (warehouse) about 230 feet (70 meters), and the industrial condominiums at 15 Hargrove Lane about 400 feet (120 meters). Industrial condominiums are business units, not homes.

Land that could become homes:

The nearest parcel zoned for multifamily (a planned development, formerly MFR-2) is about 780 feet (240 meters) to the north-northwest. The county lists it as 0.37 acre of timberland. Staff’s report places the nearest residential zoning in a tract in Palm Coast Park to the north.

The nearest larger unbuilt parcel in a planned development or mixed-use area is about 2,300 feet (700 meters) away, 12.45 acres, listed as vacant industrial. Within 1.9 miles, 441 unbuilt parcels totaling about 2,490 acres are zoned or mapped as planned development, multifamily, residential, mixed use or development of regional impact. The nearest ones are zoned industrial or planned development today, and none is a home yet.

Distances are measured outline to outline on flat ground and are accurate to a few dozen feet. They are not a survey. We show no addresses or owners of homes.


Source: Palm Coast Storylines analysis of Flagler County parcel records and City of Palm Coast zoning and future land use layers, run Nov. 17, 2026; staff report, planning board packet item D.4.

The concrete plant at 56 Hargrove Grade


In 2026 the City heard a request from Hard Rock Materials to rezone 56 Hargrove Grade, 10.44 acres, from light industrial (IND-1) to heavy industrial (IND-2) for a ready-mix concrete batch plant (Application 6185). It is a separate request, from a different company, on the same road.

Feb. 18, 2026, Planning and Land Development Regulation Board, item D.2. The board recommended approval, 5 to 2. Yes: Shank, Hilton, Stancel, Gross, Decker. No: Nicholson, Ferguson.

March 17, 2026, City Council, first reading, item H.6. The motion to approve failed, 1 to 4. Yes: Sullivan. No: Norris, Pontieri, Miller, Gambaro.

Both meetings are in our archive, with the agendas, minutes, packets and transcripts: Feb. 18 planning board and March 17 Council.


Source: City of Palm Coast approved minutes of the Feb. 18 planning board meeting and the March 17 Council meeting; meeting transcripts.

What about the smell, the particulates and the health hazards?


This is background from other places and other plants. None of it measures the plant proposed at 77 Hargrove Grade, and none of it says what its neighbors would experience.

A federal health study. In 2007 the U.S. Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry published a health consultation on a hot mix asphalt plant and a liquid asphalt terminal in Salisbury, North Carolina, using monitoring done from May to September 2001. It found no acute or chronic public health hazard from the chemicals it measured. Its concerns were particles and odor. A hydrogen sulfide reading used as an odor marker went over the smell threshold 28 times at about 100 feet (30 meters) from the terminal, 4 times at about 650 feet (200 meters), and not at all at about 1,300 feet (400 meters). Fine particles went over the health standard on one day. The agency said odors alone can cause symptoms in sensitive people. Most of the odor came from the liquid asphalt terminal, not the mixing plant, and the agency noted that equipment has changed since.

A government setback. Prince Edward Island, Canada, requires an asphalt plant, including its loading area and aggregate piles, to sit at least 500 meters (about 1,640 feet, or 0.31 mile) from non-industrial uses, to reduce dust, odor and noise. The distance can be reduced if air dispersion modeling shows the plant meets ambient standards.

Florida. The state’s general air permit for asphalt plants sets no distance from homes. See the air permit box.

Odor and standards are separate questions. In Augusta, Maine, a state study found air near a paving plant met health standards, yet neighbors less than half a mile (about 800 meters) away still called the odor a nuisance (Bangor Daily News, Feb. 2011). In Irvine, California, regulators have received more than 1,400 odor complaints about an asphalt plant and issued eight notices of violation for public nuisance (South Coast Air Quality Management District).

The links:

Salisbury, NC Air Quality and Hot Mix Asphalt Plants, Health Consultation, ATSDR, Feb. 2007 (PDF)

Asphalt Plant Guidelines, Prince Edward Island, Jan. 2024 (PDF)

“It smells but Maine asphalt plant meets standards,” Bangor Daily News, Feb. 11, 2011

All American Asphalt community investigation, South Coast AQMD


Source: the documents linked above, read Nov. 17, 2026.

Florida’s general air permit


Florida’s air rules include a general permit for asphalt plants that meet its conditions: Rule 62-210.310(4)(g) of the Florida Administrative Code. For a drum-mix plant it sets a ceiling of 600,000 tons a year, a particulate limit, an opacity limit and a stack test. It sets no distance from homes or other land uses.

A separate rule, 62-296.320(2), bars objectionable odor from any source.

Whether this plant would register under the general permit is not in the packet.


Source: Florida Administrative Code, Rules 62-210.310(4)(g) and 62-296.320(2); Florida Department of Environmental Protection, Asphalt Concrete Plant Air General Permit Informational Handout (floridadep.gov), for the permit and the 600,000-ton drum-mix ceiling.