Palm Coast
storylines...

Independent Reporting · Palm Coast, Florida
Published
Hammock Dunes  ·  The Record

The Fourth Floor, Part Two: November 10


Editor’s Note

Every other voice on this page is real: public meeting video, in their words. We do not name the family or any private resident who spoke, and the video plays as spoken.

Previously on The Fourth Floor, a family asked the Flagler County planning board for a variance that would allow a fourth floor, where only three are allowed, on a house on the ocean. On September 8, the board deadlocked, and sent the request back for more evidence.

I’m Johnny Diamond, Chief Investigative Correspondent of Palm Coast Storylines.

Chapter Two: November 10

The Hammock Dunes ; the requested variance would allow a fourth floor, as a reasonable accommodation for a child with disabilities. The county attorney sets the table.

The county attorney 5:19

The county attorney, presenting to the board.

Now, the applicant.

The applicant 1:17

The applicant, presenting.

Let’s take a look at the house. The applicant says the child wanders and has no understanding of danger. His bedroom is on the second floor. So are a flex classroom, a pool, a bowling alley, and a waterfall.

Staff said the , on all three allowed floors, without a variance.

Here are those three floors. Add eighteen feet to the side, and by our measurement that’s about thirty-eight hundred square feet. That’s roughly the size of the second floor.

The two garages are around twenty-five hundred square feet. That’s more than the median new single-family home in the United States which is about two thousand two hundred.

A number of neighbors spoke in opposition. Opposition focused on precedent, the neighborhood’s character, and whether a fourth floor is necessary.

A neighbor 1:48

A neighbor, during public comment.

A neighbor reads an email 2:35

A neighbor, during public comment.

A number of people turned out in support, as part of an organized effort by a couple of advocacy groups. They focused on the ground level not being a story because it’s a garage, and on the safety reasons behind the design. We chose two to hear: the builder, and a community advocate.

The builder 1:25

The builder, during public comment.

An advocate 2:14

An advocate, during public comment.

When public comment closed, the board took it up. One member praised the applicant’s willingness to support his son, and said he did not know that it justified the request.

Another member moved to deny, saying it was not a reasonable accommodation, and went beyond the minimum variance required.

A second member agreed. By either test, a traditional variance or a reasonable accommodation, he saw no justification.

A third member said the board had heard no substantial evidence that the family could not do this on just two floors.

The board voted five to nothing. The variance was denied.

This is an interesting story with many dynamics. The case for the fourth floor is a child who wanders and has no understanding of danger. His floor has a pool, a waterfall, and a bowling alley.

But the applicant says the house is the same height either way. So what difference does it make what’s inside?

We told the story, submitted for your consideration.

Full item, in order: Planning and Development Board, Nov. 10, 2026 (appeal 6.a and variance 6.b)

Watch this story as a film: The Fourth Floor, Part Two, on YouTube


— Johnny Diamond  ·  Palm Coast Storylines

Two votes in one night


On November 10 the board took two related items. Item 6.a was the appeal of the Planning Director’s determination that the garage level counts as a story. The board upheld the determination, five to nothing. Item 6.b was the one-story variance and reasonable-accommodation request, which the board denied, five to nothing.

The first outcome removed the family’s argument that the garage level is not a story. The second addressed the request that remained.


Source: county meeting record and video (see the clips above for the times).

The house, from the plans


The county’s packet for November 10 includes the applicant’s presentation, with a floor plan for each level and a space table. The table lists 11,628 square feet of air-conditioned living space, two garages of 1,930 and 588 square feet, 682 square feet of non-air-conditioned storage, and 20,609 square feet in all.

The second-floor plan shows a two-lane bowling alley and a three-story waterfall, with a room labeled classroom and a bedroom. Another page, titled “Second Floor Pool,” shows the pool and spa on the same floor. At the hearing the applicant’s design consultant said that floor is the one planned for the child, with the child’s classroom and bedroom.

The comparison figure is from the U.S. Census Bureau: the median size of a new single-family home sold in 2024 was 2,210 square feet.

Open the floor plans from the county’s packet (PDF, 4 pages)

U.S. Census Bureau, Characteristics of New Housing


Source: Flagler County Planning and Development Board packet, Nov. 10, 2026, pages 82, 83, 84 and 91 (the fourth-floor plan, page 85, is left out because its labels carry the family’s names); U.S. Census Bureau.

The county staff report


The staff report in the November 10 packet says that building height here “is governed by the Allowable Building Height in Stories as set forth by the Hammock Dunes DRI, rather than in a foot dimension,” and that the applicant has HOA approval for the height of the structure measured in feet (packet page 150).

On the next page staff writes that, based on the setbacks in the plat addendum, the residence “by right, could be 18’ wider on all 3 permitted stories without the need for a variance” (page 151).

The family’s variance memorandum, in the same packet, acknowledges that this alternative “may be technically permissible.” It argues that a wider house would increase the apparent mass and width of the structure, obstruct more of the neighbors’ sight lines and reduce visual openness between homes.

Open the county staff memo and technical staff report (PDF, 19 pages; the family’s names are covered)


Source: Flagler County Planning and Development Board packet, Nov. 10, 2026, pages 138 to 156 (staff) and the owner’s variance memorandum, pages 132 to 135.

The development order, page by page


The height limit is a table in Section 17.5.c of the Hammock Dunes development order. The county included it in the meeting packet it published for the November 10 hearing. The link below opens those three pages, copied from that packet exactly as the county delivered them. They are the three versions, on packet pages 24, 28 and 56: the 1984 original (three, seven and twenty stories), the 1995 amendment (the third figure cut to twelve), and the 1998 amendment (the same table).

In every version the table gives its limits in stories. In the 1995 and 1998 pages a footnote reads “Building height includes residential and garage floors,” and its asterisk is printed beside the twelve-story figure. Whether that footnote reaches the three-story row was part of the argument, and on November 10 the board voted 5 to 0 to uphold the county’s reading. The 1998 page in the packet is stamped “unofficial document.”

The packet holds pages of the order, not the full order.

Open the three pages from the county’s packet (PDF, 3 pages)


Source: Flagler County Planning and Development Board packet, Nov. 10, 2026, pages 24, 28 and 56.